The Development of American Baptist Preaching: Sermonic Theology, Form, and Practice from the Colonial Period to the Early Twenty-First Century

By Ryan Rippee

In the summer of 1775, as colonial America braced for armed conflict with Britain, Oliver Hart (1723–1795), pastor of First Baptist Church of Charleston, South Carolina, was called upon to persuade colonists to support the Patriot cause. For thirty years, Hart had mounted his pulpit in that city and preached with a consistency his eulogist Richard Furman (1755–1825) could summarize without exaggeration:

Christ Jesus, and him crucified, in the perfection of his righteousness, the merit of his death, the prevalence of his intercession, and efficacy of his grace, was…  the delightful theme of his preaching.[1]

What made Hart’s pulpit ministry remarkable was not merely its content but its form. Converted under the preaching of Jenkin Jones at Pennepek Baptist Church and further shaped by George Whitefield, Hart absorbed the Puritan plain style in full.[2] From the colonial period through the early twenty-first century, American Baptist preaching has been governed (when it has been most characteristically itself) by this plain style: a tripartite method traceable to William Perkins’s The Arte of Prophecying (1592) in which exposition, doctrinal derivation, and practical application form an organically unified act of proclamation.[3]

This article argues that the plain style represents the normative Baptist homiletical paradigm, one that has proven uniquely suited to the Baptist conviction that, as the priesthood of believers implies, “God alone is Lord of the conscience.”[4] Isaac Backus (1724–1806), the tradition’s most persistent advocate for liberty of conscience, gave this conviction its clearest early formulation, grounding it in a direct accountability to God that admits no ecclesiastical intermediary.[5] Where preacher and congregation alike stand immediately under the authority of Scripture, the sermon’s form and content must submit to the text’s own governing shape rather than to the preferences of the preacher or the expectations of the audience.

Baptist preaching history reveals a recurring oscillation: periods of fidelity to the plain style norm, departures from it under theological and cultural pressure, and recovery movements that reassert the text’s authority over the sermon’s form. Three persistent tensions thread this narrative: doctrinal precision versus popular appeal, biblical authority versus cultural relevance, and prophetic declaration versus pastoral application.

This article traces seven historical periods, analyzing each through three interlocking categories: sermonic theology (the doctrinal content and hermeneutical commitments underlying the sermon), homiletic form (the structural relationship between text and sermon), and preaching practice (the mode of delivery and manner of application). The argument concludes that the twenty-first-century, text-driven, Christ-centered expository movement constitutes the most coherent historical recovery of the Baptist homiletical tradition to date.

Part I: The Plain Style Established and First Fractured (1592–1810)

Perkins and Hart: The Plain Style Received and Practiced

The foundational method of American Baptist preaching arrived in the New World via the English Puritan tradition, especially in Perkins’s The Arte of Prophecying. In contrast to the Ciceronian style of homily that was popular in Anglican circles, Perkins articulated what would become the dominant homiletical method for the following two centuries: the preacher reads the biblical text, expounds its plain grammatical and logical sense, derives a doctrine inherent in the text, and applies that doctrine through specific uses (doctrinal, polemical, practical, and consolatory) to the congregation’s actual circumstances.[6] The organizing was textual authority: whatever the preacher said must be shown to flow from what the biblical author meant.

English Particular Baptists like Benjamin Keach (1640–1704), John Gill (1697–1771), and Abraham Booth (1734–1806) inherited and practiced this Perkins-derived plain style structure as the grammar of their pulpit ministry.[7] The Second London Confession of Faith (1689), adapted in America as the Philadelphia Confession (1742), gave this homiletical inheritance its confessional spine and anchored the Baptist preacher’s obligation to the text in a formal account of Scripture’s authority and sufficiency.[8] When Baptists arrived in earnest in the American colonies, they brought this confessional-expository heritage with them.

Within this confessional and homiletical inheritance, Oliver Hart stands as a defining figure of early Southern Baptist ecclesial formation.[9] His biographer, Loulie Latimer Owens, wrote:

South Carolina Baptists, and Southern Baptists, have no more important pioneer than Oliver Hart. It was he who furnished them with their first denominational structure when he introduced the pattern of the Philadelphia Association to the South.[10]

Hart founded the Charleston Baptist Association in 1751, traveled widely in South Carolina and Georgia promoting evangelistic preaching, and trained ministerial students in his home,linking this associational and educational work to a steady plain style pulpit in Charleston. On June 28, 1775, at the request of the South Carolina Provincial Congress, Hart preached a fastday sermon from Isaiah 59:19 (“When the enemy shall come in like a flood, the Spirit of the Lord shall lift up a standard against him”), “A Sermon Delivered on a Day Appointed for Fasting and Prayer.”[11] Following Perkins’s method, Hart (1) reads and explains the text in its immediate context, (2) states a governing doctrine: that God himself raises a standard against opposition to his church, often through Christ’s mediatorial work, and (3) unfolds a series of uses tailored to his hearers’ crisis, calling them to repentance for sin, earnest prayer, and confidence in God’s sovereign defense amid the looming conflict with Britain. The sermon’s architecture is recognizably Perkinsian, yet its tone and aims are thoroughly Baptist: the biblical text, not civil authority or ecclesiastical hierarchy, governs the exhortations laid upon a congregation of free consciences.

Roger Williams: The Prophetic Mode as Baptist Inheritance

Roger Williams (ca. 1603–1683) contributed to Baptist preaching less through sermonic method than through his foundational articulation of liberty of conscience and the limits of civil authority over religious life.[12] Educated at Cambridge and expelled from Massachusetts Bay Colony in 1636 for his “dangerous opinions,” Williams founded Providence Plantations on the principle of voluntary church membership and complete separation of civil and ecclesiastical authority.[13] His two major polemical works, The Bloody Tenent of Persecution for Cause of Conscience (1644) and The Bloody Tenent Yet More Bloody (1652), established the Baptist prophetic rhetorical mode: the preacher who stands outside established ecclesiastical order to declare the freedom of conscience before God alone.[14]

Williams’s contribution to Baptist homiletics was theological rather than methodological: he established that the Baptist preacher’s authority derived not from ecclesiastical ordination but from Scripture itself and the direct illumination of the Spirit, and therefore must be free to serve God according to Scripture and conscience. This prophetic standing outside ecclesial establishment would mark Baptist preaching in every subsequent period of crisis, from Isaac Backus’s tax-resistance pamphlets to John Leland’s First Amendment advocacy.

Backus and the Separate Baptists: The Plain Style in Revival and Liberty

The First Great Awakening’s most significant fruit among Baptists was the Separate Baptist movement. Shubal Stearns (1706–1771) and Daniel Marshall (1706–1784), originally Congregationalist Separates who embraced believer’s baptism under the influence of the Awakening, founded Sandy Creek Baptist Church in Randolph County, North Carolina, in 1755.[15] From Sandy Creek, the Separate Baptist movement spread rapidly through Virginia, the Carolinas, and Georgia, planting scores of churches within a generation. Stearns, along with many other Baptist preachers, absorbed Edwards’s emphasis on affections and extended application, producing a preaching style marked by emotional urgency, warm evangelistic appeal, and direct address to the unconverted.[16]

Isaac Backus (1724–1806) bridged the Separate Baptist and Regular Baptist traditions in New England, by 1802 compiling a record of 918 trips totaling nearly 68,000 miles, and organizing Baptist churches in Massachusetts and Connecticut on a particular Baptist confessional basis.[17] His theology, as E. Brooks Holifield has noted, represented “a conservative Baptist appropriation of Edwardean themes” that highlighted heartfelt religion and evangelism.[18] His conviction that “true religion must at all times be a matter between God and individuals” was grounded in his reading of Scripture as the direct and sole authority over conscience.[19]

His 1778 discourse, “Government and Liberty Described; and Ecclesiastical Tyranny Exposed,” exemplifies the plain style of Perkins deployed in the service of Baptist political distinctives.[20] The discourse moves from biblical exposition anchored in Amos 5:24 (“Let judgment run down as waters, and righteousness as a mighty stream”), expounding the text through six numbered observations on the nature of true liberty, to the doctrinal proposition that true religion is a “voluntary obedience unto God” and therefore cannot be coerced by any civil authority.[21] From that doctrinal center, Backus presses pointed application against the New England practice of taxing Baptists to support Congregationalist ministers: such coercion, he argues from Matthew 15, Galatians 1:8–9, and 1 Samuel 2:16, violates the very nature of the gospel it claims to protect.[22]

Thus, Backus demonstrates that the plain style is a hermeneutical commitment in which the text governs the sermon, Scripture governs conscience, and a governed conscience refuses every state encroachment on religious affairs. As J. Judd Owen has observed, “Government and Liberty Described” represents Backus’s “most systematic presentation” of the case for religious liberty, one grounded not in natural rights but in the conviction that “allowing human government, which God set over temporal affairs, any hand in maintaining or regulating the church evidently tends to destroy the purity and life of religion.”[23]

That the plain style was capable of reaching across confessional traditions, geographic frontiers, and social standing is confirmed by the ministry of George Liele (c. 1750–c. 1828), a Virginia-born slave converted through the Georgia Separate Baptist network and later the founder of the first Baptist congregation in Jamaica, whose pastoral practice, as documented in his own correspondence, reflected the identical pattern of Word ministry that Hart practiced in Charleston and Backus practiced across New England.[24]

John Leland and the First Fracture: Conscience Displaces Scripture

Yet the same Revolutionary era that produced Backus’s disciplined plain style advocacy also exposed a structural vulnerability within Baptist preaching. The figure who most clearly reveals it is John Leland (1754–1841). Leland moved to Virginia in 1777 and became the most effective Baptist itinerant in the state, claiming more than 1,200 baptisms during his fifteen years of ministry there.[25]

His political advocacy was equally consequential. When the Virginia Baptist General Committee, led by Leland, voted unanimously on March 7, 1788, that the proposed federal Constitution made insufficient provision for religious liberty, Madison’s ratification effort was in genuine peril.[26] The two men reportedly met near Leland’s home in Orange County, where Madison pledged support for a bill of rights and Leland pledged his support for Madison’s candidacy.[27] Virginia ratified the Constitution on June 25, 1788, and the religion clauses of the First Amendment followed in 1791.[28]

Leland demonstrates how the Baptist conviction that every man must give an account to God (and thus be free from ecclesiastical and civil coercion) produces a distinctive prophetic rhetorical mode.[29] Leland declared, “Every man must give an account of himself to God, and therefore every man ought to be at liberty to serve God in a way that he can best reconcile to his conscience.”[30] This principle, applied to civil governance, authorized the Baptist preacher to speak truth to political power with an authority derived not from establishment ordination but from Scripture and conscience alone.

On its surface, this sounds like Backus. The difference lies beneath, and it is homiletically decisive. Where Backus grounded religious liberty in Scripture’s sole authority over the conscience, Leland grounded it in the individual conscience’s inherent freedom to reason toward truth, an epistemology shaped as much by Jeffersonian liberalism as by Baptist theology.[31] Nathan Hatch has described Leland and the Baptist populists of his generation as embodying a democratic challenge to “all human authority” over individual religious conscience. His posture was politically effective but carried a corresponding homiletical cost.[32]

This distinction surfaces directly in Leland’s primary texts. His Rights of Conscience Inalienable (1791) does not open by announcing and expounding a biblical text. Instead, it proceeds through a series of philosophical propositions, marshaling Scripture as supporting evidence for conclusions already reached on other grounds. In other words, in Leland’s political discourses, doctrine arrives first, and the text is recruited afterward. This structural inversion of the plain style itself is the homiletical logic that topical preaching would institutionalize in the nineteenth century. Thus, a preacher formed without confessional anchors, guided primarily by occasion and individual conscience, was already positioned for the world Charles Finney would make explicit: if the occasion governs the architecture and results validate the method, then whatever produces the desired response is, by definition, sound preaching. The New Measures would accelerate a logic the Revolutionary pulpit had already set in motion.

Part II: The Plain Style Contested: Departures and Partial Recoveries (1800–1930)

Finney and Knapp: New Measures Invert the Plain Style

Charles Finney (1792–1875) gave this logic its fullest expression in the Second Great Awakening. Finney did not dismiss doctrine. In fact, he insisted that “if he preaches no doctrine, he preaches no gospel,” but he made doctrine a tactical instrument rather than a governing authority.[33] Where the Perkins-derived plain style required the preacher to derive doctrine from the text and let the text’s own argument govern the sermon’s structure, Finney required the preacher first to diagnose the congregation’s “intrenchment” (the particular error, excuse, or resistance blocking a decision), and then to select whichever doctrines would dislodge it. He said, “Find out where sinners lie, and pour in truth upon them there, and start them out from their refuges of lies.”[34]

The governing category of the sermon was always conversion; doctrine was recruited to serve that goal, and the biblical text was chosen afterward to carry the assigned persuasive weight. Finney’s soteriology confirmed what his homiletics required: conversion is “the sinner’s own act,” and the preacher is therefore “a voluntary, responsible agent” whose primary obligation is not fidelity to a text but to producing a decision.[35] The result was a structural inversion of the plain style norm.

The figure who most clearly demonstrates the transfer of these methods into Baptist churches is Elder Jacob Knapp (1799–1874). Knapp was gnawed by a conviction that while the Presbyterians had Finney, “there was no one man who stood forth as the champion and exemplar of revival measures” among the Baptists.[36] In 1833, he resigned his pastorate and took to the road. What emerged from his subsequent itinerant career was an explicit appropriation of Finney’s New Measures specifically modified for the Baptist context, what Caleb Morell has aptly called, “Finney with a Twist.”[37] Iain Murray, surveying this development, concludes that “Knapp’s book certainly proves that he was among the first of the Baptist practitioners of what he called ‘the new method of presenting the gospel.’”[38] Knapp introduced protracted meetings into Baptist churches, in which an itinerant preacher would “stay on the ground till the meeting is done,” whether days or weeks.[39] The homiletical consequence was the severance of the sermon from any Scriptural context.

Francis Wayland (1796–1865), Baptist president of Brown University, offered the period’s clearest theological diagnosis. Writing as “Roger Williams” in The Examiner (essays later collected in Notes on the Principles and Practices of Baptist Churches), Wayland looked back to an older Baptist generation whose preachers had been marked by “a simplicity of reliance on the power and grace of Christ to aid them, and render their work effectual, which have not been so apparent in later times.”[40] What distinguished those earlier ministers, Wayland argued, was precisely their total dependence on the Spirit rather than on means; their successors, by contrast, had committed what he called the opposite error of substituting excitement and method for earnest prayer and doctrinal proclamation. For Wayland, the collapse was not merely stylistic but confessional: Baptists who professed sovereignty in regeneration had adopted a homiletical apparatus that implied conversion was the predictable product of sufficient human pressure. Yet Wayland’s resistance went largely unheeded, and Knapp’s model, not Wayland’s, became the normative Baptist preaching paradigm for the following generation, carried westward through the tent revival culture of frontier expansion.

Finney’s departure affects all three categories of theology, form, and practice: his sermonic theology reduced doctrine to a tactical instrument of decision; his homiletic form inverted the plain style structure by making the anticipated response rather than the text govern the sermon’s architecture; and his preaching practice detached the sermon from any fixed scriptural context, leaving only the preacher’s diagnosis of the congregation’s resistance as its governing logic.

Booth and Furman: The Slavery Crisis and the Cost of Proof-Texting

No single episode more starkly reveals the relationship between hermeneutical method and sermonic content than the Baptist controversy over slavery. Abraham Booth (1734–1806), English Calvinist Baptist pastor, preached Commerce in the Human Species on January 29, 1792, a sermon whose plain style biblical argument against the slave trade crossed the Atlantic to shape American Baptist antislavery thought.[41] Booth examined Old Testament texts about slavery with grammatical and contextual care, distinguishing between the regulated servitude of ancient Israel (time-limited, ethnically particular, hedged with humanitarian provisions) and the race-based chattel slavery of the modern Atlantic trade. His exposition was contextual: individual texts must be read within the moral logic of the whole canon.

Richard Furman (1755–1825), first president of the South Carolina Baptist State Convention, offered a starkly different hermeneutic. His 1822 address, Exposition of the Views of the Baptists Relative to the Coloured Population of the United States argued that the Scriptures sanctioned slavery on the basis of Old Testament precept (Leviticus 25) and New Testament silence.[42] Furman’s hermeneutic was selective and proof-textual: individual texts were marshaled in service of a social conclusion rather than read within the moral arc of the whole canon.

The Francis Wayland–Richard Fuller exchange of 1844–1845, published as Domestic Slavery Considered as a Scriptural Institution, brought this hermeneutical conflict to denominational crisis.[43] Wayland argued from the principle of liberty inherent in the gospel, tracing a canonical argument from the law of love, the equal dignity of persons before God, and the moral arc of redemptive history. Fuller defended the institution from specific, individually cited texts, employing the same proof-textual method Furman had modeled. The 1845 founding of the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC) was the institutional result of that unresolved dispute. What the slavery controversy reveals for Baptist homiletics is this: eisegesis is both a hermeneutical error and a homiletical one. The proof-texting topical method liberates the preacher to use the Bible rather than be governed by it.

John A. Broadus: The Plain Style Codified for Recovery

In 1870, five years after a war that had exposed the catastrophic cost of selective biblical interpretation, John A. Broadus (1827–1895) published what would become the most widely used preaching manual in American history.[44] Founding professor of New Testament and homiletics at the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, Broadus produced A Treatise on the Preparation and Delivery of Sermons under circumstances that were anything but auspicious: one student remained in his post-war homiletics class, and that student was blind.[45]

The Treatise was a sustained attempt to re-anchor Baptist preaching in grammatical-historical exegesis, doctrinal content derived from the text, and application shaped by the text’s own governing intention. Broadus grounded his homiletical method explicitly in both theology and rhetoric. In the introduction to the Treatise, he wrote:

Homiletics may be called a branch of rhetoric, or a kindred art. Those fundamental principles which have their basis in human nature are of course the same in both cases, and this being so, it seems clear that we must regard homiletics as rhetoric applied to this particular kind of speaking. Still, preaching is properly very different from secular discourse, as to the primary source of its materials, as to the directness and simplicity of style which become the preacher, and the unworldly motives by which he ought to be influenced.[46]

His doctrine of Scripture completed the foundation. Broadus stated plainly:

Wherever the Bible undertakes to teach, its teachings are true. It does not attempt to teach on all subjects. It uses popular language that must be interpreted accordingly. But whatever it intends to teach, that is paramount in authority.[47]

When Crawford Toy, Broadus’s colleague at Southern Seminary and its professor of Old Testament, embraced higher critical views that undermined the historical reliability of Scripture, Broadus advised James Petigru Boyce to require Toy’s resignation, even at high personal cost.[48]

Two of Broadus’s sermons, “He Ever Liveth to Intercede for Us” (Hebrews 7:25) and “Let Us Have Peace with God” (Romans 5:1), illustrate his method. In “He Ever Liveth,” Broadus engaged the imagination with the wonder of Christ’s intercession through Scripture alone, not “flowery or inflammatory language.” In “Let Us Have Peace with God,” he methodically expounded a single verse, explained justification, clarified the nature of faith through a homespun illustration, and drove the doctrine home in extended application.[49]

Yet the same honesty that requires acknowledging Broadus’s homiletical achievement demands acknowledging its limits. Broadus was personally a slaveholder, served as a Confederate chaplain, and publicly defended slavery as a righteous institution, moral failures that were enabled by the selective proof-texting the plain style was designed to prevent.[50] That a preacher of Broadus’s exegetical sophistication could practice grammatical-historical exposition on Romans 5 and Hebrews 7 while applying Furman’s proof-textual method to texts about human dignity is the period’s most sobering lesson: homiletical recovery, to fulfill its own logic, must be applied consistently across the whole canon.

B.H. Carroll: Canonical Preaching as Inerrantist Recovery

Benajah Harvey Carroll (B.H. Carroll, 1843–1914), founder of Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary and author of the seventeen-volume An Interpretation of the English Bible, represented the inerrantist-expository response to the advance of German higher criticism into American seminaries.[51] From the pulpit of First Baptist Church of Waco, where he served for twenty-eight years, Carroll’s sermons were consumed with explanation of the biblical text, including its context, its language, and its place within the whole counsel of Scripture.

What distinguishes Carroll’s preaching from both the essay sermon and standard expository preaching is what Matz describes as “canonical preaching.” Carroll’s sermons bring the whole counsel of the canon to bear on the meaning of a single passage, tracing theological themes across the entire biblical narrative to provide what he believed was a complete understanding of a text’s subject.[52] Rather than expounding a single passage in a linear fashion, he built what was essentially a sermon-length biblical theology on a text-derived theme (often through extended word studies), so that his “canonical” preaching operated as a doctrinally driven form of topical preaching.

Finally, Carroll’s conclusions were typically brief and almost always took the form of a direct evangelistic appeal. As Matz observes, “The gospel stood as the culmination of his every sermon, while the invitation to respond to the gospel was always the sermon’s proper application.”[53] Through the preaching of his students at Southwestern, that pattern of ending doctrinally rich sermons with a succinct gospel invitation has become a recognizable feature of Southern Baptist preaching and has largely endured to the present.

Walter Rauschenbusch: The Social Gospel Displaces the Text

Walter Rauschenbusch (1861–1918) came to his convictions through eleven years of pastoral ministry at the Second German Baptist Church in Hell’s Kitchen, in New York City. Here he faced the poverty, exploitation, and institutional indifference that industrialism had concentrated in Manhattan’s most crowded precincts.[54] By the time he returned to Rochester as a professor in 1897, Rauschenbusch had determined that the church’s primary failure was not doctrinal but social; that it had, as he argued in Christianity and the Social Crisis (1907), “uncoupled the religious and the social life” in defiance of Jesus’s own purpose, which was nothing less than “a thorough regeneration and reconstitution of social life” through the establishment of the kingdom of God.[55] As Charles Howard Hopkins documented in his definitive history of the period, the social gospel’s institutional penetration (from denominational boards to seminary curricula to the Federal Council of Churches) was comprehensive and rapid, reaching full organizational expression between 1900 and 1915.[56]

Rauschenbusch did not challenge the plain style so much as quietly displace it. This displacement is visible in the architecture of Christianity and the Social Crisis itself, which functions as the period’s representative sermon-essay. The book opens with a social diagnosis: “Western civilization is passing through a social revolution unparalleled in history for scope and power.”[57] From that opening, Rauschenbusch moves through the Hebrew prophets, the social aims of Jesus, the failure of the institutional church, and the demands of the present crisis, with each chapter governed by the social question it is designed to answer rather than by the biblical material it draws on. Scripture appears throughout, but always in a secondary, illustrative capacity: the prophets are marshaled as proto-social reformers, Jesus’s teaching is translated into a program for social reconstruction, and the kingdom of God is redefined as the social order to be built through human cooperation with divine purposes.

Dare We Be Christians? (1914), Rauschenbusch’s most explicitly sermonic work, confirms the pattern. Built nominally on 1 Corinthians 13, the book uses Paul’s chapter on love as a launching pad for an extended essay on social solidarity. Rauschenbusch reads Paul’s demand for love not as a theological claim about the nature of divine charity poured into the human heart by the Holy Spirit, but as a demand for “the social instinct, the power of social coherence, the sine qua non of human society.”[58] The exegetical argument is minimal; the social application is total. Paul’s categories are evacuated of their theological content and refilled with the categories of Progressive Era sociology. What results is formally a sermon on 1 Corinthians 13, and structurally an essay on the social demands of the present moment.

This is the essay-sermon format that Harry Emerson Fosdick explicitly theorized in his celebrated 1928 Harper’s essay, “What Is the Matter with Preaching?” Fosdick declared that the conventional expository method—in which the preacher “takes a passage from Scripture and, proceeding on the assumption that people attending church that morning are deeply concerned about what the passage means,” spends his time on “historical and exegetical material”—had “long since lost its influence over intelligent people.”[59] In its place Fosdick proposed the “project method”: the preacher starts with “a live issue, a real problem—personal or social, perplexing to the mind or disturbing to the conscience,” faces it squarely, and “throws such light on it from the spirit of Christ that the people will go out able to think more clearly and live more nobly.”[60]

By the second decade of the twentieth century, the Baptist pulpit was divided between two departures: 1) the revivalist expediency that Carroll’s inerrantist recovery had partially arrested in Southern Baptist churches, and 2) the social gospel topicalism that had colonized the Northern Baptist mainstream. Rauschenbusch’s homiletical legacy proved remarkably durable: the essay sermon format he exemplified became the default mode of the educated Protestant pulpit for the better part of a century, and its structural logic (issue determines text, application precedes exposition, the congregation’s social condition governs the sermon’s shape) has never fully left the Baptist tradition.

Part III: The Plain Style Renovated and Recovered (1930–2021)

Lee and Hobbs: Inerrancy Confessed, Plain Style Abandoned

By the second quarter of the twentieth century, the Baptist pulpit had inherited two generations of departure from the plain style norm. The revivalist expediency that Carroll had partially arrested and the social gospel topicalism that had colonized the Northern Baptist mainstream had, between them, established the audience-centered sermon as the de facto homiletical form. Among conservative Southern Baptists, inerrancy was affirmed with conviction, but the pulpit method had not kept pace.

R.G. Lee (1886–1978), pastor of Bellevue Baptist Church in Memphis and three-term SBC president, is illustrative of this trend. His sermon “Payday Someday” was preached over 1,000 times and is arguably the most celebrated Southern Baptist sermon of the century.[61] It was a rhetorically brilliant and narratively vivid declaration of divine judgment on Ahab and Jezebel, but “Payday Someday” derived its power not from grammatical-historical exposition but from narrative reconstruction, rhetorical amplification, and Lee’s own formidable oratorical gifts.[62] The plain style norm was honored in its confessional commitments; it was not practiced in its structural method. Lee represented the median Southern Baptist pulpit: evangelistic, orthodox, warm in pastoral application, but structurally topical-applicatory rather than text-driven. The governing question of the sermon had shifted, almost imperceptibly, from “What does this text mean?” to “What does this congregation need?”

Though Fosdick’s theology was liberal, his homiletical logic mirrored what conservative Baptist revivalism had already institutionalized: occasion-governed form, audience-dictated content, and text deployed for authority rather than obeyed as structure.[63]

W.A. Criswell: The Grassroots Recovery of the Plain Style

W.A. Criswell (1909–2002) illustrates how the mid-century recovery of the plain style arose as much from pastoral discovery as from institutional design. Criswell arrived at First Baptist Church of Dallas in 1944 as a topical preacher in the mid-century mold, inherited the library and sermon notes of his predecessor A.N. Hall, and found that Hall had preached through virtually the whole Bible, text by text. Criswell asked:

Why should I struggle to think up topics for my sermons…when I could let inspiring and informative texts speak for themselves?…Suddenly, I found myself really proclaiming the Word, book by book, text by text, cover to cover from Genesis to Revelation. I felt new power.[64]

Criswell’s subsequent preaching through the entire Bible over seventeen years (1952–1969) offered a widely imitated model of text-driven exposition for a generation of Southern Baptist ministers.[65] His Christ-centered approach also retrieved a distinctive feature of earlier generations:

There is one great theme of the Word of God. The theme is constant from beginning to end. That theme is Jesus. He is on every page, in every event, in every type, in every book. Someone once asked the famed Charles Haddon Spurgeon of the Metropolitan Tabernacle in London, “Why do all of your sermons sound alike?” Spurgeon replied, “Because I take a text and make a beeline to the cross.” The entire Bible presents Jesus, and the man who wants to proclaim Christ must do so by preaching from all the Word of God.[66]

This Christocentric expository method (text-driven in structure, cross-centered in content) planted the seeds that the text-driven movement would later cultivate into a full hermeneutical principle. Criswell’s expository conversion gave the recovery its first institutional foothold: the largest Southern Baptist congregation in the world was now pastored by an expositor, and within a generation that model would become the denominational aspiration.

Inerrancy in the Pulpit: The Rise of Christ-Centered, Text-Driven, Expository Preaching

That consolidation came through the Conservative Resurgence in the Southern Baptist Convention, launched in 1979. The Resurgence is most often described as a battle over inerrancy. Still, its most enduring legacy may be homiletical: inerrancy, once recovered as a confessional commitment, was now being pressed as a hermeneutical practice. Adrian Rogers (1931–2005), pastor of Bellevue Baptist Church in Memphis and three-time SBC president, represented the theological and homiletical vision of the Resurgence most fully. His sermon series through Romans, Ephesians, and Revelation modeled consecutive expository preaching for a generation of Southern Baptist pastors formed in topical-applicatory methods. Rogers articulated the grounding plainly:

For a preacher to be powerful, he must be authoritative, and he cannot be authoritative unless there is a sure word from God. There was a time when preachers would stand in the pulpit, hold up the Word of God, and say, “The Bible says.” Then they started saying, “The church says.” Now they just scratch their heads and say, “Well, it seems to me.”

The inerrancy of the Bible equips the preacher with authority in the pulpit, for it supplies the preacher with the right to stand up and declare, “Thus saith the Lord.” When the Bible speaks, God speaks. That puts a ring of authority into what the preacher has to say. The preacher is not a demagogue, he is not an authoritarian, but there is no stutter, no stammer, no apology. There is no backing away from preaching the Word. He should never be guilty of testing the temperature of the water. What the Bible says, he must say.[67]

Rather than a stylistic preference, expositional preaching carries a theological obligation flowing from the nature of Scripture itself.

What Rogers represented in the pulpit, the Resurgence institutionalized in the seminaries. R. Albert Mohler Jr., appointed president of The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary in 1993, rebuilt the institution around confessional commitment to inerrancy and reformed its homiletics curriculum toward a text-driven method.

The methodological codification followed. Jerry Vines (b. 1937), two-time SBC president and longtime pastor of First Baptist Church, Jacksonville, joined with Jim Shaddix, then a rising homiletics professor who would serve as professor of preaching at New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary and later occupy the W. A. Criswell Chair of Expository Preaching at Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary, to publish Power in the Pulpit: How to Prepare and Deliver Expository Sermons in 1999.[68] Their five-step process gave readers a codified, reproducible method that seminaries could teach and pastors could practice. By the close of the twentieth century, expository preaching was the stated ideal across SBC seminaries, even where practice lagged, but a question remained: what governed the content of an expository sermon? The text now determined the structure. Toward what end?

The plain style, as Perkins defined it and Hart practiced it, was always more than a structural method. Its governing purpose was the exposition of Christ from every text. The Puritans did not want to explain what the text merely said, but to show how it pointed to and was fulfilled in the person and work of Jesus Christ.[69] The twentieth-century recovery had restored the method; the twenty-first-century movement restored the content.

At Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary, Danny Akin’s 2007 commitment to text-driven, Christ-centered exposition represented the convergence of the Conservative Resurgence’s confessional gains with the recovery of an expositional homiletical program.[70] That commitment was codified in Text-Driven Preaching: God’s Word at the Heart of Every Sermon (2010), co-edited by David L. Allen and Ned Mathews. Text-driven preaching, as the volume defines it, attends to three dimensions of the biblical text: its substance (what the text says), its structure (how the text says it), and its spirit (the tone and emotional register in which the text communicates). The sermon must replicate all three. Thus, the text’s own literary form is itself communicative, and the preacher who renders a lament as a doctrinal outline or flattens a narrative into a list of propositions has failed to preach the text even while explaining its content.[71]

The Baptist preacher formed by the text-driven method returns to the discipline Hart and Broadus practiced: the sermon’s structure submits to the text’s own governing shape. However, the history of American Baptist preaching has raised a question that structural recovery alone cannot answer. The plain style’s original purpose was theological and formative. Its governing aim, as the Puritans practiced it and the Baptist tradition received it, was always the exposition of Christ from every text. Form without that content and method without that theology leaves the Baptist pulpit with a disciplined structure pointing nowhere in particular.

Conclusion: The Norm, the Departures, and the Ongoing Call

When William Perkins insisted that “the sum of the whole Bible is Christ,” he was naming its governing purpose. The Baptist preachers who received that tradition (Hart, Backus, Broadus, Carroll, Criswell, Rogers) understood, however inconsistently they practiced it, that faithful exposition is not merely explanation of a text but proclamation of the one to whom the text ultimately bears witness.

Christ-centered expository preaching, as this history demands it be defined, begins with the conviction that divine revelation is progressive, and its goal is the revelation found in Jesus Christ. Because he is the theme and goal of all Scripture, the preacher’s exegetical obligation is not merely to establish what the text says but to show how the text stands in relation to Christ: his righteousness, his cross, his intercession, his all-sufficient provision for the people of God. As Bryan Chapell has observed, this is “not merely an interpretive method; it is an exegetical obligation with necessary implications for the saving and sanctifying messages we preach.”[72] A sermon that explains the text but never arrives at the Savior may not fail methodologically, but it does theologically.

This is why the departures documented in this survey are, finally, theological failures. When Finney subordinated the text to the revival decision, he displaced the sufficiency of Christ with the sufficiency of method. When Rauschenbusch subordinated Scripture to social diagnosis, he displaced the supremacy of Christ with the urgency of the moment. The congregation, in each case, was left without the only help adequate to the human condition. The twenty-first-century text-driven movement has recovered the plain style’s structural architecture. What remains is the ongoing call that has sounded across every Baptist recovery: to preach Christ from every text, in the power of the Spirit, for the glory of the Father, so that the church is not merely informed but delivered, comforted, and transformed. May it be said that “Christ is his own attraction” in every faithful Baptist pulpit.


[1]     Richard Furman, G. William Foster, and Wood Furman, Life and Works of Dr. Richard Furman, D.D. (Harrisonburg, VA: Sprinkle Publications, 2004), 337.

[2]     Richard Furman recorded that, of the Great Awakening preachers, Hart “has since professed to have received much benefit from their preaching, particularly from Mr. Whitefield’s.” Furman, Life and Works of Dr. Richard Furman, D.D., 335.

[3]     William Perkins, The Arte of Prophecying (Edinburgh: Banner of Truth Trust, 1996), originally published 1592/1606. For Perkins’s tripartite structure and its transmission to American colonial preaching, see Eugene White, “Puritan Preaching and the Authority of God,” in Preaching in American History, ed. DeWitt T. Holland (Nashville, TN: Abingdon, 1969), 36–73.

[4]     The Baptist Faith and Message (Nashville, TN: Southern Baptist Convention, 2000), Article XVII, “Religious Liberty.” The full statement reads: “God alone is Lord of the conscience, and He has left it free from the doctrines and commandments of men which are contrary to His Word or not contained in it.”

[5]     Isaac Backus developed this account of direct accountability across multiple pamphlets, locating the principle in Scripture’s own authority over conscience. See Isaac Backus, Government and Liberty Described (Boston, MA: 1778), and A Door Opened for Christian Liberty (Boston, MA: 1783).

[6]     Perkins, The Arte of Prophecying, 54–79. See also White, “Puritan Preaching,” 36–73, and Horton Davies, The Worship of the English Puritans (Morgan, PA: Soli Deo Gloria, 1997), 182–203.

[7]     For the English Particular Baptist adoption of Perkins’s method, see Michael A. G. Haykin, “‘Those Who Plead for Thee’: Particular Baptist Preaching and the Plain Style in the Long Eighteenth Century,” Evangelical Quarterly 94, no. 4 (2023): 299–311.

[8]     Ch. 1 (“Of the Holy Scriptures”), The Second London Confession of Faith (1689); The Philadelphia Confession of Faith (1742).

[9]     Loulie Latimer Owens, Oliver Hart, 1723–1795: A Biography (Greenville, SC: Southern Baptist Historical Collection, Furman University, 1966), 12–8.

[10]    Owens, Oliver Hart, 1.

[11]     Oliver Hart, A Sermon, Delivered on a Day Appointed for Fasting and Prayer: Isaiah 59:19 (Charleston, SC: n.p., 1775).

[12]    Larry Witham, A City Upon a Hill: How Sermons Changed the Course of American History (New York: HarperOne, 2007), 22–5.

[13]    Edwin S. Gaustad, Liberty of Conscience: Roger Williams in America (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 1991).

[14]    Roger Williams, The Bloody Tenent of Persecution for Cause of Conscience (1644); Roger Williams, The Bloody Tenent Yet More Bloody (1652). Both reprinted in The Complete Writings of Roger Williams, 7 vols. (New York: Russell & Russell, 1963). Some modern citations update “Tenent” to “Tenet.”

[15]    Anthony L. Chute, Nathan A. Finn, and Michael A. G. Haykin, eds., The Baptist Story: from English Sect to Global Movement (Nashville, TN: B&H Publishing, 2015), 78–81.

[16]    Aaron L. Lumpkin, “‘Some Agreeable Conversation’: Jonathan Edwards among Early American Baptists,” Perichoresis 21, no. 2 (2023): 34–49.

[17]    Bruce L. Shelley, “Backus, Isaac,” in Biographical Dictionary of Evangelicals, ed. Timothy Larsen (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2003), 43–4. See also William G. McLoughlin, Isaac Backus and the American Pietistic Tradition (Boston, MA: Little, Brown, 1967).

[18]    E. Brooks Holifield, Theology in America: Christian Thought from the Age of the Puritans to the Civil War (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2003), 282–83.

[19]    Isaac Backus, Government and Liberty Described; and Ecclesiastical Tyranny Exposed (Boston, 1778), in Isaac Backus on Church, State, and Calvinism: Pamphlets, 1754–1789, ed. William G. McLoughlin (Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1968), 351; Isaac Backus, A Door Opened for Christian Liberty (Boston, 1783), in McLoughlin, Pamphlets, 431.

[20]    Backus, Government and Liberty Described, in McLoughlin, Pamphlets, 345–66.

[21]    Backus, Government and Liberty Described, in McLoughlin, Pamphlets, 351.

[22]    Backus, Government and Liberty Described, in McLoughlin, Pamphlets, 362–65.

[23]    J. Judd Owen, Making Religion Safe for Democracy: Transformation from Hobbes to Tocqueville (Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press, 2014), 4–8. Owen notes that for Backus, liberty was not “self-determination” but “the flow of mercy and grace from God to men” (Government and Liberty Described, in McLoughlin, Pamphlets, 350), and that Backus supported disestablishment in order to remove human interference from the work of the Holy Spirit, not to vindicate natural rights.

[24]    George Liele, letter to Dr. John Rippon, and letter to the editor of the English Baptist Annual Register, both quoted in George Liele’s Life and Legacy: An Unsung Hero, ed. David T. Shannon (Macon, GA: Mercer University Press, 2013), 47–8. For Liele’s conversion within the Georgia Separate Baptist network, see Carter G. Woodson, The History of the Negro Church (Washington, DC: Associated Publishers, 1921), 41–4. No extant sermon manuscripts permit analysis of Liele’s rhetorical method; what the sources establish is the structural and doctrinal continuity of his ministry with the broader plain style Baptist pattern.

[25]    L. F. Greene, ed., The Writings of the Late Elder John Leland (New York: G. W. Wood, 1845), 13–4; on his life, see John Leland: A Jeffersonian Baptist in Early America, Eric C. Smith (New York: Oxford University Press, 2022).

[26]    Robert B. Semple, A History of the Rise and Progress of the Baptists in Virginia, rev. ed. G. W. Beale (Richmond, VA: Pitt and Dickinson, 1894), 73–4.

[27]    Joseph Spencer to James Madison, February 28, 1788, in The Papers of James Madison, vol. 10, eds. Robert A. Rutland et al. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1977), 542–43.

[28]    Smith, John Leland, 75–83.

[29]    For John Leland’s ministry and political theology, see Greene, Writings of John Leland.

[30]    John Leland, The Rights of Conscience Inalienable (1791), reprinted in Greene, Writings of John Leland, 179–92.

[31]    Mikael N. Broadway, “The Ways of Zion Mourned” (PhD diss., Duke University, 1993), 219–20, demonstrates that the Rights of Conscience Inalienable paraphrases approximately 200 words from Jefferson’s Notes on Virginia, confirming that its organizational logic is Jeffersonian rather than expository.

[32]    Nathan Hatch, The Democratization of American Christianity (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1989), 97.

[33]    Charles G. Finney, Lectures on Revivals of Religion (1835), ed. William G. McLoughlin (Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1960), 189.

[34]    Finney, Lectures, 195–96.

[35]    Finney, Lectures, 186, 188. On the sinner as “author of the change,” Finney says: “The sinner actually changes, and is therefore himself, in the most proper sense, the author of the change.”

[36]    Jacob Knapp, Autobiography of Elder Jacob Knapp (New York: Sheldon, 1868), 41.

[37]    Caleb Morell, “‘Finney with a Twist’: Elder Jacob Knapp and the Origins of Baptist Revivalism,” 9Marks, June 14, 2022, https://www.9marks.org/article/finney-with-a-twist-elder-jacob-knapp-and-the-origins-of-baptist-revivalism/. Morell’s analysis of Knapp’s two distinctly Baptist innovations—instantaneous baptisms and child baptisms—traces the polity consequences of the New Measures in Baptist church life, consequences that fall outside the homiletical scope of the present article but illuminate the breadth of Knapp’s departures from established Baptist norms.

[38]    Iain H. Murray, Revival and Revivalism: The Making and Marring of American Evangelicalism, 1750–1858 (Edinburgh: Banner of Truth, 1994), 312. For the broader transition of Baptists from the plain style to the topical method of the New Measures, see 301–28.

[39]    Finney, Lectures on Revivals of Religion, 221, 224; Knapp, Autobiography, 28.

[40]    Francis Wayland, Notes on the Principles and Practices of Baptist Churches (New York: Sheldon, Blakeman & Co., 1857), 22–3.

[41]    Abraham Booth, Commerce in the Human Species (London: n.p., 1792), reprinted in The British Particular Baptists, 1638–1910, vol. 2, ed. Michael A.G. Haykin (Springfield, MO: Particular Baptist Press, 2000), 187–221. Booth corresponded with Baptist ministers in Philadelphia on the question of American slavery, and Furman would later name him as a threat that his Exposition was written to answer. For Booth’s direct engagement with American Baptist audiences, see “American Slavery, A Letter to the Rev. Dr. Rogers, of Philadelphia, from the Late Rev. Abraham Booth,” The Baptist Magazine 31 (1839): 527–29.

[42]    Richard Furman, Exposition of the Views of the Baptists Relative to the Coloured Population of the United States (Charleston, SC: n.p., 1823), reprinted in Richard Furman: Life and Legacy, James A. Rogers (Macon, GA: Mercer University Press, 1985), 274–86.

[43]    Francis Wayland and Richard Fuller, Domestic Slavery Considered as a Scriptural Institution (New York: Lewis Colby, 1845).

[44]    Eric C. Smith, Between Worlds: John A. Broadus, The Southern Baptist Seminary, and the Prospects of the New South (Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 2026), 187; David S. Dockery, ed., John A. Broadus: A Living Legacy (Nashville, TN: B&H Academic, 2008), 5.

[45]    Smith, Between Worlds, 181–83.

[46]    John A. Broadus, A Treatise on the Preparation and Delivery of Sermons, ed. Edwin Charles Dargan, New (23d) ed. (New York: Hodder & Stoughton, 1898), 16.

[47]    John A. Broadus, Catechism of Bible Teaching (Philadelphia, PA: American Baptist Publication Society, 1891), 15.

[48]    Dockery, John A. Broadus, 14; A. T. Robertson, Life and Letters of John Albert Broadus (Philadelphia, PA: American Baptist Publication Society, 1901), 298–305.

[49]    For analysis of Broadus’s preaching, see Hershael W. York, “John Albert Broadus: Carefully Expositing the Authoritative Scriptures,” in A Legacy of Preaching, Volume Two: Enlightenment to the Present Day, ed. Benjamin K. Forrest, Kevin L. King, Bill Curtis, and Dwayne Milioni (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan Academic, 2018), 211–27.

[50]    Southern Baptist Theological Seminary released a 71-page report in 2018 documenting that its four founding faculty members (Boyce, Broadus, Basil Manly Jr., and Williams) together enslaved more than fifty persons, and that Broadus publicly defended slavery as a righteous institution. See Report on Slavery and Racism in the History of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary (Louisville, KY: Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, 2018).

[51]    B.H. Carroll, An Interpretation of the English Bible, 17 vols., ed. J.B. Cranfill (Nashville, TN: Broadman Press), 1948.

[52]    Robert Matz and Jerry Sutton, “B.H. Carroll: Preaching Sermons Saturated with Scripture,” in A Legacy of Preaching, 268.

[53]    Matz and Sutton, “B.H. Carroll,” 276.

[54]    Witham, A City Upon a Hill, 187–89.

[55]    Walter Rauschenbusch, Christianity and the Social Crisis (New York: Macmillan, 1907), 42.

[56]    Charles Howard Hopkins, The Rise of the Social Gospel in American Protestantism, 1865–1915 (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1940), 215–24.

[57]    Rauschenbusch, Christianity and the Social Crisis, 1.

[58]    Walter Rauschenbusch, Dare We Be Christians? (New York: Pilgrim Press, 1914), 14.

[59]    Harry Emerson Fosdick, “What Is the Matter with Preaching?” Harper’s Magazine 157 (July 1928): 133–34.

[60]   Fosdick, “What Is the Matter with Preaching?” 135.

[61]    Robert G. Lee, Pay, Day—Someday and Other Sermons (Nashville, TN: Broadman Press, 1957).

[62]    Charles A. Fowler, “R.G. Lee: Rhetorical Artistry in the Pulpit,” in A Legacy of Preaching, 381–94.

[63]    Billy Graham (1918–2018) represented the fullest global expression of this paradigm. His sermonic theology was firmly inerrantist; his homiletic form was decision-oriented and application-first; his preaching practice was shaped by the conviction that his calling was that of evangelist, not expositor, a calling he saw as “neglected and even denigrated during much of the church’s history.” Billy Graham, Just As I Am: The Autobiography of Billy Graham (New York: HarperCollins, 1997), 687.

[64]    W.A. Criswell, Standing on the Promises: The Autobiography of W.A. Criswell (Dallas: Word, 1990), 153.

[65]    David L. Allen, “W. A. Criswell: Expositing the Whole Counsel of God—From Genesis to Revelation,” in A Legacy of Preaching, 409–27.

[66]   Hochul Song, “A Critical Examination of W. A. Criswell’s Sermons from Acts in Comparison with his Theology of Preaching” (PhD diss., New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary, 2011), 68.

[67]    Joyce Rogers, Love Worth Finding: The Life of Adrian Rogers and His Philosophy of Preaching (Nashville, TN: Broadman and Holman Publishers, 2005), 167. For an in-depth evaluation of Rogers’s preaching, see Johnny Derrick Yelton, “The Evangelistic Emphasis in the Pastoral Preaching of Adrian P. Rogers” (PhD diss., Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, 2013).

[68]   Jerry Vines and Jim Shaddix, Power in the Pulpit: How to Prepare and Deliver Expository Sermons (Chicago, IL: Moody, 1999, rev. 2017). Shaddix also held an adjunct teaching role at Golden Gate Baptist Theological Seminary (now Gateway) between 2006 and 2012.

[69]   For the Christ-centeredness of the Puritans, see Joel R. Beeke, “The Preaching of the Word,” in Feed My Sheep: A Passionate Plea for Preaching, ed. Don Kistler (Morgan, PA: Soli Deo Gloria, 2002).

[70]    Daniel L. Akin, “Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary and Text-Driven Preaching,” Journal for Baptist Theology and Ministry 4, no. 2 (2007): 88–95.

[71]    David L. Allen, Daniel L. Akin, and Ned L. Mathews, eds., Text-Driven Preaching: God’s Word at the Heart of Every Sermon (Nashville, TN: B&H Academic, 2010). The emphasis on genre-sensitivity (that the sermon should replicate the text’s literary form) distinguishes text-driven preaching from Haddon Robinson’s “Big Idea” method, which abstracts a single propositional idea from the text regardless of genre. See Biblical Preaching: The Development and Delivery of Expository Messages, 3rd ed., Haddon W. Robinson (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, 2014).

[72]    Bryan Chapell, Christ-Centered Preaching: Redeeming the Expository Sermon (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker, 2005), 311.