Chris Chun, ed. The Complete Works of Andrew Fuller, Volume 10, On Universalism and Particular Redemption, Berlin, Boston: De Gruyter Brill, 2025. Pp. I-XIII, 1-194, $126.99 hardcover.
The recent scholarly renaissance in research on the influential Baptist theologian and minister, Andrew Fuller, has culminated in the publication of the first critical edition of Fuller’s complete works with Michael Haykin serving as the General Editor. Gateway Seminary’s church historian, Chris Chun, has recently completed Volume 10 of this series that is projected to be at least 17 volumes or more. Apologetic Works 6: On Universalism and Particular Redemption, collects several of Fuller’s most critical theological conversations that deal, in different ways, with Fuller’s defense of and contributions to classical Christian soteriology. The material reproduced in this volume represents aspects of Fuller’s most mature and carefully reasoned theological reflection. It gives substance to why C. H. Spurgeon was moved to describe Fuller as the “greatest theologian” of his time.
The volume is divided into two major sections. The first deals with Fuller’s polemic against Universalism and the second with Fuller’s theological reflections concerning the proper nature and character of the Atonement.
The first section, “Letters to Mr. Vidler on Universal Salvation,” reproduces an increasingly tempestuous correspondence between Fuller and his acquaintance William Vidler. As a consequence of the Enlightenment’s acidic rationality aspects of Universalism, Socinianism, and Unitarianism found their way not only into parts of the Church of England but several non-conforming churches as well. Fuller saw this development as representing a grave danger to the church. “Letters” is a somewhat overlooked but fascinating conversation Fuller undertook with Vidler as Vidler’s views migrated from the generic Calvinism of his youth towards both Universalism and Unitarianism. Fuller engaged what he saw as this alarming trajectory with intellectual acumen and passionate intensity. Chun chronicles how the correspondence begins with Fuller’s evident pastoral concern for Vidler personally and escalates as he assesses Vidler to have succumbed to the process of being drawn into the destructive “whirlpool of Socinianism.” In his introduction, Chun chooses to document not only Vidler’s own biography, but also others—such as Elhanan Winchester and Richard Wright—who were instrumental in Vidler’s acceptance of Universalism.
Fuller’s conversation with Vidler consists of eight letters Fuller wrote to Vidler roughly between the years of 1793 and 1801. In his introduction, Chun selects portions from the fourteen letters Vidler wrote back to Fuller in order to fill in the other side of this two-way correspondence. Chun also creates a helpful table that visually displays side by side the major developments and publications in the careers of both Vidler and Fuller so that the debate between them can be seen against the actual setting in which it unfolds. Chun guides the reader through the correspondence by highlighting the character of each letter—for example, some letters are identified as dealing primarily with hermeneutical and exegetical issues, another is designated as arguing against universalism, and he stipulates that the last letter is dedicated specifically to building the case for particularism.
The second section, consisting of “Six Letters from AF to R. Jr. 1803” and a set of imaginative dialogical constructions Fuller dubs simply as “Three Conversations on imputation, substitution and particular redemption,” presents the reader with some of Fuller’s most widely researched and carefully analyzed theological reflections on the atonement proper. According to Chun, in these dual contributions on the character and nature of the atonement Fuller’s “theological depth, sophistication and subtlety are on full display.” If “Letters to Mr. Vidler” represent Fuller’s polemic against what he saw as dangers coming from the theological “left,” “Six Letters and Three Conversations” embody Fuller’s defense and apologetic of the orthodoxy of his own views from a questioning of them coming from the theological “right.” Abraham Booth was a friend of Fuller’s who journeyed from an Arminian position to a fervently held classically reformed perspective. With all the ardor of a convert, Booth feared that Fuller, under the influence of the “new lights” from America, had compromised his earlier positions and may now be espousing “governmental” or even “Grotian” views on the atonement. “Six Letters” is a correspondence written to John Ryland Jr, a mutual friend of both Booth and Fuller. Rather than evaluating the “accuracy” of Fuller’s interpretation, Chun wisely opts to alert the reader instead to five key “themes” critical to Fuller’s defense of his position:
1) the “as if” language in the doctrine of imputation and in John Calvin’s theology in relation to the question of whether “imputation” should be understood in a literal or a figurative sense; 2) the notion that Christ suffered God’s wrath without being punished; 3) Fuller’s idea that Christ’s death was sufficient for all but is applied only to the elect; 4) the concept of “transfer” in the imputation of sins to Christ, as well as Christ’s righteousness to believers; and finally 5) the distance Fuller places between himself and Richard Baxter, and Fuller’s alignment with John Owen and Jonathan Edwards. (Chris Chun, “Editor’s Introduction,” p. 49)
The second part of the second section of this volume presents a fictional conversation between three avatars—“Peter” (clearly a stand in for Booth), “James” (representing Fuller), and a mediating presence “John” (personifying Ryland). While use of this fictional dramatic convention to explicate theological nuance was hardly unique to Fuller, “Three Conversations” is, nonetheless, a creative and effective evocation of Fuller’s mature theological perspective on the atonement. Chun contributes to state-of-the-art Fuller scholarship by reporting on a previously untranslated and overlooked 1823 Welsh bilingual publication of “Three Conversations” whose introduction includes one of the earliest commentaries on the Booth/Fuller debate. He includes a brief translated excerpt from that monograph that affirms Fuller’s belief in the necessity and appropriateness of some degree of “figurative” interpretation with respect to the “commercial” metaphor when applied to the atonement. Fuller explicitly distances himself from Tobias Crisp’s insistence on some kind of “ontological” identification of Christ with sin. Just as Chun pauses to discuss several figures that had been influential in Vidler’s theological development, he similarly gives the reader guidance into some of the major influences on Fuller’s theological development—namely, Richard Baxter, John Owen, and Jonathan Edwards.
I had the privilege of seeing an early version of Dr. Chun’s volume and am pleased to report that the final version displays the same historical objectivity, narrative interest, and incisive analysis as did that original draft. In his introduction, Chun successfully balances an interesting narrative with rigorous technical information reserved largely to the footnotes. In other words, Chun succeeds in incorporating scholarly detail along with attention to the attendant critical apparatus and references to relevant scholarship while at the same time keeping his introduction interesting and even captivating. In short, Chun has produced a commentary that is at one and the same time scholarly, responsive, readable, and engaging.
This volume in particular, along with the series in general, will, at a minimum, be the definitive resource for Fuller scholarship for generations to come and, more likely, in perpetuity. Anyone interested in Fuller’s work will find this volume not only a mandatory read but an invaluable vein to mine. Haykin and Chun have produced a work that should be a part of any significant theological library in the English-speaking world.