Anthony L. Chute, Nathan A. Finn, and Michael A. G. Haykin. The Baptist Story: From English Sect to Global Movement. Second edition. Brentwood, Tennessee: B & H Academic, 2025. 539 pages. $47.99.
Textbook revisions, along with other forms of refreshing texts, do not often get reviews. Reviewers have little incentive to revisit these works. Publishers have little financial incentive since textbook adoption tends to be sticky. However, these revisions can impact how a teacher assigns readings or how future historians assess the historiography. Campell’s review in Criswell Theological Review, Duesing’s review in Midwestern Journal of Theology, and Rathel’s review in Baptist Quarterly agree on the core details of the first edition; their disagreements in the first edition are about teaching preferences. Each praises the book’s readability for those unfamiliar with Baptists and acknowledge the brevity of the discussion of Anabaptism. Another feature related to readability is the editorial decision not to footnote the text, but to have a works cited section. For readability, my agreement on the various points of historiographic emphasis, and price point, I have used the first edition since 2017.
The chapters mostly follow the same titles as the first edition. The authors moved “Baptist Identity and Distinctives” to the beginning of the book. They renamed “Developments into the 21st Century” as “Recent Developments in Baptist Story.” They added a new conclusion. Finally, they added a glossary and an abbreviation list to the back matter. All these changes are welcome updates that improve accessibility to the reader. If a professor prefers an inductive teaching approach, the introductory chapter could still be read at the end of a course, but defining what a Baptist is can help move the reader along.
The Table of Contents level analysis doesn’t tell the story of the update. First, the first edition chose feathered edges on cropped ovals for the pictures, which made the images hard to read. All the pictures are now a normal block shape, and some have been replaced with better images. Chapter 1 Question 5 is now two questions. Chapter 13 no longer includes the section on global Baptist movements, which is now Chapter 14. The authors introduced additional content in Chapters 13 and 14, including women in ministry, race, sexual abuse, trends toward post-denominationalism, and expanding beyond Australia to Oceania in Chapter 14. Relevant questions have been updated, relocated, and created to support the additional content. Nine of the chapters have an updated bibliography. As a librarian, the updated bibliography makes me happy.
In the closing paragraph of “Living Under the Cross,” there is a copyediting issue. “This defense of British slavery and its attendant barbarities seriously skewed the Scriptures, as we shall see in chapter 4.” (page 102 in 2025; page 58 in 2015) The chapter ordering update means that the first edition refers to “Renewal and Advance.” The second edition would refer to “The Age of Reason and Revival.” The chapter “The Age of Reason and Revival” does not discuss slavery in Great Britain. This oversight can happen to any author who uses signposting and chooses to revise their book.
The revisions are similar in aim and instruction to the revision of Bebbington’s Baptists Through the Centuries, which is the nearest serious competitor textbook. The price point for both ebook and physical copy is cheaper for The Baptist Story. The decision for perfect binding makes the print edition more accessible. This trend toward perfect binding cuts costs at the expense of the book’s long-term usability. B&H is not the only publisher that has made this decision. The only recent Baptist History textbook with a sewn binding in my collection is The Story of Baptists in United States by Durso and Durso. (Durso and Durso is also 20 years old at this point.) After the first printing, Oxford made the same decision with Baptists in America by Kidd and Hankins. This reduced durability trend does not encourage students to reference their textbooks in future ministry. Therefore, there is no other option in the market that is not subject to this same critique.
This observation regarding the broader landscape and The Baptist Story’s function as a reference tool shows a gap in the field. McBeth’s Baptist Heritage is 39 years old. Brackney’s Genetic History is out of print. Garrett’s Baptist Theology is print on demand. I see nothing in the market that would function as an elective higher-level Master’s Baptist Studies course text or Ph.D. seminar volume. It is unfair to judge this textbook for not being a book they did not intend to write. The critique would be as fitting as complaining about how few Presbyterians are mentioned in The Baptist Story. Yet, the gap in the market remains.
The Baptist Story, 2nd edition, is an enjoyable narrative of the Baptist tradition. Joseph Early, Jr.’s Readings in Baptist History continues to be a fitting supplementary primary source anthology. The addition of a glossary and updated questions provides good tools for developing quizzes and other assessments.