Book Review: 40 Questions about Mormonism

By Travis Kerns

The 40 Questions series from Kregel Academic, with more than 30 titles in the series, includes works dealing with every issue from hermeneutics to Bible translation to eschatology to world religions. One of the newest volumes, 40 Questions about Mormonism, stands then in a long line of works devoted to answering, well, 40 questions dealing with the given topic of the particular volume. With a Ph.D. focused on Latter-day Saint history from Southern Baptist Theological Seminary and personal experience working with Latter-day Saints, Kyle Beshears is well-equipped to write the volume.

Beshears breaks the volume into five parts: “Studying Mormonism,” “The Story of Mormonism,” “Authority in Mormonism,” “The Beliefs of Mormonism,” and “Approaching Mormonism.” Part one, “Studying Mormonism,” is focused on why Christians should study Mormonism and includes a concise history of how Christians have approached Latter-day Saints. Chapter one asks why Christians should study Latter-day Saints and, in summary form, Beshears answers, “Because we are commanded to love our neighbors as ourselves, and it’s hard to love someone without taking the time to get to know them. Only then may we move forward together” (23). Thus, the author argues we should study Latter-day Saints to get to know them for the purpose of moving forward together. Chapters two and three work through varying ways Christians have approached Latter-day Saints historically, and Beshears briefly surveys reasons ranging from avoiding foolishness to exposing false religion to evangelizing those caught up in counterfeit Christianity. Ultimately, Beshears argues Christians should concern themselves with “obedience to the Great Commandment” (23) as the fundamental reason for engaging Latter-day Saints.

Part two, “The Story of Mormonism,” provides a short history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints with three chapters devoted to some aspect of the life of Joseph Smith, two chapters dealing with the Latter-day Saint movement to the Intermountain West, and other chapters on the great apostasy, various groups within the larger Mormon movement, and the American nature (or not) of the tradition. Though very concise due to page limit constraints, this part of the book is a mostly straightforward presentation of the history of Latter-day Saint history and does not generally differ from other historical presentations.

Part three, “Authority in Mormonism,” aims at both canonical and contemporary authority in Latter-day Saint theology and practice. Beginning with the Latter-day Saint understanding of the Bible and progressing through the history and storyline of the Book of Mormon, the Doctrine & Covenants, and the Pearl of Great Price, this part ends with a concise discussion of the priesthood, a vital aspect of Latter-day Saint theology, especially (although it is not discussed) when continuing revelation is taken into consideration.

Part four, “The Beliefs of Mormonism,” focuses on what Beshears terms “key doctrines” and “unique doctrines.” Those key doctrines include Theology Proper, Christology, Pneumatology, anthropology, soteriology, and ecclesiology whereas the unique doctrines range from eternal progression, modern temples, baptism for the dead, and the Latter-day Saint health code. As this part of the book unfolds, Beshears works through what amounts to a compare/contrast style of explanation, especially in those beliefs in the “Key Doctrines” subheading.

Finally, part five, “Approaching Mormonism,” is Beshear’s discussion of and preferred for talking to Latter-day Saints. Except for the introductory part on the why and how of studying Latter-day Saints, this is the shortest of the five parts. He begins by discussing concerns Latter-day Saints have about Christianity, moves to whether Christians should pray about the truthfulness of the Book of Mormon, and ends with a two-part discussion about dialogue between Christians and Latter-day Saints.

Having studied The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints at the undergraduate, graduate, doctoral, and post-doctoral levels for 30 years; having worked to share the message of Christ personally with Latter-day Saints throughout the same time period; having trained others to do the same; and having lived in Utah as a full-time Christian missionary for six years, I am a self-professed Mormon nerd. Anytime a new book or article is published in Mormon studies, whether from a Mormon or non-Mormon perspective, I read it. So, when I heard of Beshears’s work I was intrigued to read it (and maybe more so than others because we are both Ph.D. graduates of Southern Baptist Theological Seminary with major doctoral professors in common).

Before embarking on a critical interaction of the book, it is important to know of divergent Christian paths when it comes to the study of and interaction with Latter-day Saints. In his excellent 2025 Ph.D. dissertation at Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, Benjamin Sutton catalogs those approaches and summarizes them into two categories, counter-cult and relational, and then proposes his own approach, what he terms “gospel-centric.” I wholeheartedly agree with Sutton’s gospel-centric methodology and could not disagree more with the relational approach. Nonetheless Beshears stands firmly and unquestionably in the relational category.

Though there are positives throughout the book, like the succinct summaries of Latter-day Saint history, explanations of events in Joseph Smith’s life, and basic outlines of Latter-day Saint beliefs, the negatives far outweigh the positives such that this book should not be recommended to any reader who does not have a strong understanding of both Latter-day Saint studies and historic, orthodox, evangelical Christianity because one could easily be led to believe that Latter-day Saints are Christians, just not traditional ones. Unfortunately, this line of thought emerges as early as the second sentence of the Introduction when the phrase “traditional Christian” is first found. Although seemingly innocuous at first glance, within Latter-day Saint studies this phrase is often used to compare “traditional Christians” with “Latter-day Saint Christians.” To be fair, Beshears never uses “Latter-day Saint Christians,” but the phrase “traditional Christians” assumes there are other types of Christians in the world, and with 300+ pages of information on Latter-day Saints to follow without information to the contrary being presented, the inference is easily drawn. Indeed, even the final part of the book in which Beshears offers his instruction to “traditional Christians” as they interact with Latter-day Saints, nowhere is explicit gospel proclamation said to be needed because Latter-day Saints are not Christians. Rather, dialogue for mutual understanding is the proposed route forward.

Moreover, the tone of the book tends more toward an apologetic for accepting Latter-day Saints into the Christian world rather than an explanation of Latter-day Saint beliefs with the goal of informed gospel proclamation in mind. For example, Beshears argues Joseph Smith’s claims are not accepted by Christians because of how he went about asserting his claims rather than the information within the claims themselves (52). Similarly, in a question about Latter-day Saint theology proper, Beshears’s first sentence is, “Traditional Christians and Latter-day Saints share many of the same convictions about God” (171). This statement is misleading at best. While similar terms are used by Christians and Latter-day Saints about the nature of deity, there is a fundamental, unbridgeable divide between the God of Christianity and the deity of Latter-day Saints. The divide is indeed so wide between the two faith traditions simply on the nature of deity that the two stand fundamentally opposed. In perhaps the worst example, Latter-day Saint theology is said to be heterodox (174) rather than heretical. Heterodoxy is not conforming with accepted orthodoxy whereas heresy stands opposed to orthodoxy. Put simply, Latter-day Saint theology is not heterodox, it is heresy. It is opposed to Christian orthodoxy. Joseph Smith himself made the same claim about Christianity. He claims Christ told him, “those professors were all corrupt; that: ‘they draw near to me with their lips, but their hearts are far from me, they teach for doctrines the commandments of men’” (Joseph Smith – History 1:19).

Christians are commanded to share the gospel with all unbelievers, not dialogue with them for mutual understanding. While it is true that we must be loving in our gospel presentations, we cannot use the Great Commandment to override the Great Commission. When we forsake the explicit Great Commission, we have lost our way.