Introduction
Jonathan Edwards was dying. It was the spring of 1758, and Jonathan had recently become the new president of the College of New Jersey, now known as Princeton University. Shortly after taking up his new post, Jonathan was inoculated against smallpox. Unfortunately, as sometimes happened with eighteenth-century inoculations against the dread disease, he developed a full-blown case of smallpox and his health declined rapidly. As he lay dying, Jonathan wrote the following in a letter to his daughter Lucy:
Dear Lucy, It seems to me to be the will of God, that I must shortly leave you; therefore give my kindest love to my dear wife, and tell her, that the uncommon union, which has so long subsisted between us, has been of such a nature, as I trust is spiritual, and therefore will continue forever: and I hope she will be supported under so great a trial, and submit cheerfully to the will of God. And as to my children, you are now like to be left fatherless; which I hope will be an inducement to you all, to seek a father who will never fail you.1
Seven months later, Sarah followed her husband into the next life when she died of dysentery. If Jonathan was right about their “uncommon union” being spiritual and enduring into eternity, then their matrimony is now but one aspect of the “world of love” that comprises the heaven of Jonathan’s theological vision.
Recent decades have witnessed ongoing interest in Jonathan Edwards by scholars and among pastors and other ministry leaders. Many of the former, and most of the latter, are evangelicals. With every passing year, there are new monographs, dissertations, book chapters, journal articles, and reprints of primary sources. There is also a constant stream of online content related to Edwards, ranging from the edifying to the thoughtful to the scholarly. As a general rule, much of the attention Edwards has received from scholars and the most thoughtful popular writers relates to four broad topics: 1) Edwards’s biography; 2) his thought (including theology, philosophy, ethics, and exegesis); 3) his role in interpreting and promoting revival; and 4) his theological legacies throughout the English-speaking world and beyond. In this essay, I will reference all four, though I will especially focus upon biography.
Both scholarly and popular authors have periodically given attention to Jonathan’s family life, and especially his marriage to Sarah. I will survey treatments of Jonathan and Sarah Edwards’s relationship by various interpreters who have written on this topic since World War II. My goal is not to offer a fresh reading that breaks new ground, but rather to survey the lay of the land in terms of how different scholars and popular writers have interpreted the Edwards marriage. At the conclusion, I will also offer some suggestions about further lines of research that could be pursued by graduate students and other interested scholars.
Interpretations
As a general rule, the Edwards marriage has been interpreted four different ways. Many historians and some popular writers have put forward biographical interpretations that focus on the historical details of Jonathan and Sarah’s relationship. Others, mostly popular writers, offer exemplary readings of the Edwards marriage. A number of scholars and some biographers have advanced what might be called a spiritual interpretation of the uncommon union. Finally, at least one scholar has commended a theological account of Jonathan and Sarah’s marriage. In addition to these interpretations of the marriage itself, an additional topic that attracted recent interest among scholars is Jonathan and Sarah’s understanding of slavery, since it was related to their domestic life together. I will survey each of these interpretations in turn.
Biographical Interpretations
Although Ola Winslow wrote a Pulitzer Prize-winning popular biography of Jonathan Edwards in 1940, Perry Miller’s 1949 intellectual biography is often considered to mark the beginning of sustained scholarly emphasis upon Edwards.2 Beginning in 1953, Miller became the first general editor of the critical edition of The Works of Jonathan Edwards, published by Yale University Press in twenty-six hardcover volumes as well as another fifty-two online volumes.3 Miller and subsequent scholarly biographers have included historical accounts of Jonathan and Sarah’s marriage. As a general rule, they have treated Sarah as a secondary, though crucial character in their respective narratives of Jonathan’s life and ministry.
Miller discusses Jonathan’s first mention of Sarah in his “Apostrophe to Sarah Pierpont,” written shortly before Jonathan became pastor of the Congregational Church in Bolton, CT in 1723.4 They married four years later, shortly after Jonathan was called to serve with his grandfather Solomon Stoddard in Northampton, MA. Miller also mentions George Whitefield’s glowing assessment of Sarah and her role in Jonathan’s ministry following Whitefield’s 1740 visit to Northampton.5 That same year, in his Personal Narrative, Jonathan rehearsed his own spiritual biography and compared it with young Sarah Pierpont, whom he believed loved God and embodied authentic piety by the time he met her when she was thirteen.6 Sarah experienced her own personal awakening under the preaching of Samuel Buell in 1742, which Jonathan recounted, without naming Sarah, in Some Thoughts Concerning the Revival of Religion (1742).7 Miller tells how Sarah learned of Jonathan’s death in 1758 while the two were apart. As mentioned earlier, Jonathan was in Princeton while Sarah was still preparing to relocate the household from Massachusetts to their new home.8 A few odds and ends of their marriage are also mentioned, though these facts seem of lesser concern to Miller.
In his 2003 Bancroft Prize-winning biography, George Marsden includes all the material referenced by Miller, but in almost every case expands the narrative. To give just one example, Marsden devotes an entire chapter to Sarah’s spiritual awakening in 1742 and how contemporaries such as Jonathan, George Whitefield, and Samuel Hopkins interpreted her piety; the latter two considered her a model Christian wife and mother.9 Marsden also adds further details to our portrait of the Edwardses’ marriage. He notes that Jonathan and Sarah “reared eleven children and nurtured what became an American dynasty.”10 He also recounts in far greater detail the circumstances of Jonathan and Sarah’s earliest interactions, Jonathan’s thoughts on her youthful spirituality, his blossoming romantic feelings for Sarah, and their shared love of music.11 Marsden also reflects upon the Edwardses’ explicitly spiritual understanding of sexuality.12
Marsden focuses far more than Miller upon the everyday details of the Edwardses’ marriage, including their settling into Northampton,13 their family devotional practices,14 Sarah’s domestic responsibilities,15 her sense of style and shopping habits,16 and her relationship with household slaves.17 He also mentions how others admired Sarah as a role model for how she handled suffering and death, including that of several children and ultimately Jonathan himself.18 Marsden also regularly interweaves information about the births and exploits of the Edwardses’ children into his narrative.
In 2008, Marsden wrote a second biography titled A Short Life of Jonathan Edwards as part of Eerdmans’s Library of Religious Biography series. He added little new content in this latter work, though he does spend some time speculating about how Jonathan may have struggled with sexual desires toward Sarah during the years prior to their marriage. Marsden suggests, “Perhaps it was that the married state transformed his sexual desire from being a spiritually demoralizing distraction to a gift of God to celebrate.”19 Perhaps not surprisingly, this particular topic features far less prominently among Edwards’s more popular and pastoral biographers.
Edwards’s final scholarly biographer is Philip Gura, author of Jonathan Edwards: America’s Evangelical (2005). Gura covers much the same ground as Marsden, recounting the narrative of Jonathan and Sarah’s courtship leading up to their marriage. Also like Marsden, Gura notes that spirituality and sexuality were related in Jonathan’s developing feelings toward Sarah.20 Gura also includes a lengthy section dedicated to Samuel Buell’s influence upon Sarah and her struggles with measuring Jonathan’s ministry effectiveness against that of Buell and notes Jonathan’s subsequent acceptance of Sarah’s spiritual awakening under Buell and inclusion of her testimony in Some Thoughts Concerning the Revival of Religion.21
Exemplary Interpretations
Following in the line of some of Edwards’s contemporaries such as Whitefield and Hopkins, several authors have advanced exemplary readings of the Edwardses’ marriage, often focusing upon Sarah’s piety in particular. The Edwardses thus function as role models for modern Christians, and Sarah in particular demonstrates what it means to be a godly wife. References to Sarah’s godliness and its role in Jonathan’s ministry can be found in dozens of books about topics such as biblical womanhood, faith-based parenting, Christian leadership, and even American exceptionalism. Some authors put forward exemplary readings in greater detail.
In his 1987 popular biography, Ian Murray focuses upon the affection between Jonathan and Sarah, their devotion to Jesus Christ, and their partnership in ministry.22 He frequently draws upon sympathetic voices from past centuries to frame his own interpretations of the Edwardses. For example, he quotes Samuel Miller, a nineteenth-century biographer: “Perhaps no event of Mr Edwards’ life had a more close connexion with his subsequent comfort and usefulness that this marriage.”23 Not surprisingly, Murray’s lengthiest discussion of Sarah focuses upon her personal spirituality, especially in the wake of Buell’s preaching in Northampton. In his telling, Murray relies on sympathetic contemporary accounts of Sarah’s piety.24 Murray does provide some details that are lacking in the more scholarly biographies such as Sarah’s role in advocating for a higher salary for her husband25 and her nursing a dying uncle.26 He also includes as an appendix a 1750 letter from Sarah to Northampton officials wherein she defends he husband’s integrity in the wake of the communion controversy that resulted in Jonathan’s termination from his Northampton pastorate.27
More recently, Nöel Piper, who is married to retired pastor and popular Reformed theologian John Piper, authored a chapter that focuses upon Sarah’s role as Jonathan’s wife and ministry partner. Piper recounts the courtship of Jonathan and Sarah, covering familiar ground in terms of the general historical narrative. She also confesses her indebtedness to Elizabeth Dodds’s work, which will be discussed next.28 Piper, like her more famous husband, is a strong advocate for a complementarian understanding of gender roles. As such, she highlights the way Sarah’s personal godliness and faithful execution of her domestic responsibilities, including often bearing the brunt of the parenting load, freed Jonathan to focus on pastoral ministry and his work as a theologian.29 As Piper notes, “life in the Edwards house was shaped to a large degree by Jonathan’s calling.”30 Piper also discusses the role Sarah played as a spiritually minded hostess whose domestic gifts also blessed visitors and lodgers who found their way to the Edwards home.31 Piper closes with an admonition for modern evangelical women to follow Sarah’s example as a godly wife, mother, and individual believer.32 Much of Piper’s chapter was subsequently reworked into the first chapter of her 2005 book Faithful Women and Their Extraordinary God.33
As mentioned above, Piper’s interpretation of the Edwards marriage is in many ways a more overtly theological application of Elizabeth Dodd’s 1971 partly fictionalized biography of Sarah, titled Marriage to a Difficult Man: The Uncommon Union of Jonathan and Sarah Edwards.34 If Google is any indication of such things, Dodd’s book has become something of a modern classic, and remains especially popular among conservative evangelical women. Dodd focuses on the role that Sarah played in managing the Edwards household and supporting Jonathan’s ministry, though, as the title indicates, Dodd also suggests this was a sacrificial service that came at times with great psychological cost to Sarah. Dodd draws upon what is known about the Edwards marriage from the few available sources and supplements it with her own imagination, as evidenced in her speculations about Sarah’s mental health during seasons of the marriage. On the whole, Dodd portrays Jonathan and Sarah as loving and tender toward each other, in regular need of each other’s personal and spiritual encouragement. They were intentional partners in Jonathan’s ministry to the people of Northampton and later Stockbridge.
Another lesser-known historical novel is Edna Gerstner’s 1995 book Jonathan and Sarah: An Uncommon Union.35 Gerstner was the wife of the Reformed theologian John Gerstner, a scholar of Jonathan’s thought who, along with Banner of Truth publishers, helped introduce a generation of evangelicals to Jonathan Edwards between the early 1960s and early 1990s. This interest in Edwards paved the way for more widely discussed emphasis on Reformed theology among many evangelicals in the English-speaking world since the turn of the century.36 Edna’s book was actually written in the mid-1960s, but was not published until 1995. She hits on the same themes as Dodd’s work, but Gerstner is even more overtly pietistic in her interpretations. She focuses specifically on the period from 1750 to 1758, when the Edwards family lived in Stockbridge following Jonathan’s dismissal from his Northampton pulpit. Theirs was a model of Christ-centered marriage, even during the most difficult season of their lives when they ministered on the frontier and dealt with a greater degree of sickness and death than they had to endure in earlier years. Naturally, Sarah in particular is a historical role model for contemporary evangelical women to emulate in terms of personal piety and wifely and motherly giftedness.
Spiritual Interpretations
As George Claghorn argues, “Popular writers have … [created] a romantic, idealized picture of the relationship between Jonathan and Sarah, often picking up on his description of their marriage as an ‘uncommon union.’ Yet the importance of his relationship to Sarah was always its spiritual nature.”37 Many scholars agree, contending that Sarah (as well as David Brainerd) became models for Edwardsean piety as Jonathan sought to commend his version of revival-friendly Calvinistic evangelicalism to his contemporaries. For example, Doug Sweeney argues:
Sarah stood out clearly among the Christians of her day as an evangelical role model, a woman of vital faith. . . . Edwards often used females as examples of genuine piety, most prominently in his well-known Faithful Narrative (1737). But none of the women whom he heralded for the beauty of their faith proved to him as emblematic of earnest, evangelical holiness, or nearly as influential on the evangelical movement, as his own wife Sarah.38
Several authors develop this theme in some detail.
In her 1980 book Jonathan Edwards, Pastor: Religion and Society in Eighteenth-Century Northampton, Patricia Tracy discusses two key texts also highlighted by most biographers: Jonathan’s 1723 apostrophe on Sarah and his recollection of her awakening in 1742’s Some Thoughts Concerning the Revival of Religion. She suggests that, to Jonathan, Sarah was “an exemplar of the purest piety” and that Jonathan “use[d] Sarah’s experiences as a model of the conversions toward which he was trying to lead all of New England.”39 In Some Thoughts, Jonathan ends his description of what Tracy calls Sarah’s “remarkable holiness” with a heartfelt desire for all people to experience the same spiritual awakening as his wife.40 Sharon James covers much the same ground, albeit in a more pietistic tone, in a 2003 book chapter dedicated to Sarah’s spirituality and its validation of Jonathan’s spiritual vision.41
In a 1992 book chapter, Amanda Porterfield focuses on the Puritan context of Sarah’s spirituality and how it was reshaped through the emphases arising within the nascent evangelical movement. According to Porterfield, “The religious experiences of Sarah Edwards, as interpreted through the psychology of her husband Jonathan, may be seen as illustrating the vitality of Puritan spirituality at the moment of its culmination and transformation in the religious enthusiasms of the Great Awakening.”42 Porterfield especially highlights the bridal language so common within Puritan spirituality and echoed in Sarah’s own recollections of her spiritual experiences. Spirituality and sexuality were closely related, at least at the level of terminology. “For Jonathan Edwards, as for earlier Puritans, religious love not only drew individuals to God, it drew couples together in love affairs that partook of the beauty of the universe. In such love affairs two become one in a union that mirrored and celebrated the nature of God.”43 James McClendon also develops this theme in his theological account of the Edwardses’ marriage, to be discussed below.
In a recent dissertation, Elizabeth Friend examines Sarah’s spiritual biography in detail, comparing her with the sixteenth-century Catholic mystic Theresa of Avilla. Friend argues that Sarah’s “spiritual narrative offers a portrait of Puritan spirituality and the experiences of revival that occurred in New England during the second [sic] Great Awakening.”44 Friend contextualizes Sarah’s spiritual narrative in the context of the Puritan discipline of writing spiritual autobiographies and, like most other interpreters, she argues that Sarah served as a model for Jonathan’s understanding of authentic religious affections. Sarah’s spirituality embodied many of the emphases found within earlier Puritan spiritual autobiographies, but it also evidenced many of the qualities of the emerging evangelical spirituality that was becoming prominent in the eighteenth century, especially a clear sense of assurance of salvation.45 Sarah was thus a transitional figure in the realm of female spiritual autobiographies. Friend emphasizes that Jonathan and Sarah collaborated in crafting Sarah’s testimony included in Some Thoughts Concerning the Revival of Religion, with some portions of the original manuscript written in Sarah’s hand and others reflecting Jonathan’s handwriting.46
Friend also measures Sarah’s autobiography through the lens of Jonathan’s Treatise Concerning Religious Affections (1746). Sarah exhibited some of the negative signs identified by Jonathan that do not confirm an authentic work of God, but she also exhibited several of the positive signs that attested to true spirituality. Sarah practiced what Jonathan preached.47 More recently, three scholars affiliated with the Jonathan Edwards Center at Yale University published an article that serves as a critical reception history of Sarah’s testimony. They show how the document was edited in stages by Jonathan and Sereno Edwards Dwight, Jonathan’s great-grandson and editor of a widely used nineteenth-century edition of Edwards’s works. Sarah’s revivalistic spirituality was actually quite radical and even subversive of the gender hierarchy in New England. Jonathan and Dwight took steps to ensure the narrative would be interpreted as edifying rather than controversial.48
William Shea takes a somewhat different approach in an essay about the relationship between the Edwardses’ family life and Jonathan’s theology. Shea argues that Jonathan and Sarah’s love for each other, as well as their love for their children, shaped Jonathan’s thought, including his spiritual life, his ecclesiology, his understanding of pastoral ministry, and his vision for Puritan New England.49 For Shea, Sarah’s spirituality shaped Jonathan’s piety. Jonathan not only held Sarah up as a model for Edwardsean spirituality, as is commonly suggested, but Sarah also functioned as a model of authentic Christian piety to Jonathan himself.50 Jonathan’s love for Sarah and his esteem of her spiritual vitality never waned but rather grew over time. Her testimony, including her spiritual awakening of 1742, only confirmed Jonathan’s earliest intimations of Sarah. She was, for Jonathan, and he hoped for other New England Puritans, “a fulfillment of the old Puritan type of sainthood” as well as “an example of his new definition of true religion.”51 In another brief essay, Perry Beam offers a similar interpretation of Jonathan’s “Apostrophe to Sarah Pierpont,” which Beam suggests is really a work about Jonathan’s own spirituality rather than Sarah’s.52
A Theological Interpretation
In 1986, theologian James William McClendon wrote the first entry in what would become a three-volume systematic theology from a postliberal Baptist perspective. McClendon titled his first volume Ethics, and following the path he blazed in his earlier book Biography as Theology, McClendon frames his theological vision around the lives of individuals who exemplified his emphases.53 Similar to Porterfield, McClendon focuses upon the “embodied life” and “erotic friendship” shared by Jonathan and Sarah.54 He argues that their sexual and spiritual attraction to each other were both quite real, and reinforced each other, coloring how both Jonathan and Sarah interpreted Sarah’s spirituality, which functioned as a test case for Jonathan’s own thought. McClendon recounts all the familiar parts of the Edwardses’ narrative, interpreting them through the lens of love toward God and one another.
For McClendon, spiritual love, whether directed upward toward God or sideways toward Sarah, functioned as the link that held Jonathan’s life and thought together.55 Love was even at the root of Jonathan’s hellfire preaching in “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” and his controversial membership policy that all church members should be visible saints who could testify to being personally converted. McClendon also argues that Jonathan’s organizing principle of “love understood as cordial and general consent to being” animated his theological agenda during the Stockbridge years when he wrote his great theological and philosophical works.56 This view of love was central to Jonathan’s two dissertations, assumed in his treatise on free will, transgressed in his work on original sin, and would have colored his entire theological program had he been able to revise The History of the Work of Redemption into a comprehensive body of divinity like he had planned before his untimely death.57 For McClendon, Jonathan was an eighteenth-century narrative theologian whose love for God and love for his wife mutually reinforced one another and, in turn, mutually informed his entire theological program.
The Edwardses and Slavery
In recent years, scholars have devoted increased attention to Jonathan Edwards and slavery.58 Most scholars focus on Jonathan’s justification of human enslavement, his opposition to the transatlantic slave trade, and his possible influence upon later Edwardsean pastors who adopted abolitionism, most notably Jonathan Edwards Jr.59 However, several works since the turn of the century give attention to how Jonathan and Sarah were both active in actually enslaving at least eight individuals, beginning with a fourteen-year-old girl named Venus (or perhaps Leah), whom they purchased in 1731.60 Slavery was part of the fabric of the Edwards family, though their ownership of slaves was an indication of their elevated social class rather than any racial animus toward individuals of African descent.
In his monograph Race and Redemption in Puritan New England, Richard Bailey notes several times in the 1740s and 1750s that Jonathan mentioned to various correspondents that Sarah was interested in acquiring household slaves to help with domestic duties.61 While Bailey only mentions the Edwardses together in passing, Sean McGever gives greater attention to this issue in his recent book Ownership: The Evangelical Legacy of Slavery in Edwards, Wesley, and Whitefield.62 McGever notes that both Jonathan and Sarah “had grown up in houses and among extended family that enslaved Black people.”63 McGever discusses the same correspondence as Bailey, suggesting that the move to Stockbridge gave a greater sense of urgency to Sarah’s desire for more slaves to help keep the house in order.64 In a much-cited article titled “Jonathan Edwards’s Defense of Slavery,” Kenneth Minkema argues “Sarah, who was regulator of the domestic sphere was probably more directly concerned in the daily oversight of the family slaves than Jonathan, aggressively searched out potential slaves, which shows that women could take an active hand in the slave market.”65
Whatever Sarah’s personal views—and the sources are limited—Jonathan was certainly no pro-slavery advocate during the latter years of his life. Chris Chun has argued that the overall trajectory of Jonathan’s views was away from affirmation of slavery, even if he never took the final step—which would have been highly unusual in his context—of freeing all his slaves and speaking out against the institution. Chun writes,
Edwards was, indeed, a slaveholder in pre-revolutionary America, but he was on a journey on the issue. He grew up defending slavery and owning slaves, but as he aged, he came to denounce the slave trade. His son, and most significant protégé, Samuel Hopkins, became leaders in the nascent abolitionist movement built, in large measure, on theological foundations they had been schooled in and inherited from Edwards Sr.66
John Lowe, who has written the most recent major work on Edwards and slavery, takes a similar view. According to Lowe, “Edwards represents a transitional—and yet pivotal—moment in the narrative of New England antislavery in the way he denounced the trade while remaining an enslaver himself.”67
Slavery was part of and parcel of the eighteenth century, and there was no formal anti-slavery movement in the American colonies until the latter half of Jonathan Edwards’s life. Owning slaves was consistent with Jonathan and Sarah’s family heritage, their theological convictions, and their ascending station in life. Their slaves were just as much a part of their household as their children. Jonathan believed in the spiritual equality of his slaves, which remained in tension with their social station. As uncomfortable as this is for us today, one of the ways that Jonathan demonstrated his love for Sarah was by seeking slaves to ease her burden of managing their household. Thus, their views on enslavement, while by no means unique to their time and place, should nevertheless be taken into account when interpreting their marriage. Though perhaps exemplary in most ways, not all of Jonathan and Sarah’s marital priorities and practices should be embraced by modern evangelicals. Though counterfactual history is tricky business, it is at least reasonable to hope that, had Jonathan and Sarah lived two decades longer, their views on this matter would have aligned with younger men such as Samuel Hopkins and their own son, Jonathan Edwards Jr., both of whom exemplified Edwardsean opposition to human enslavement.
Conclusion
In closing, we might ask the question, “Will the real Jonathan and Sarah Edwards please stand up?” Were they simply a leading evangelical pastor and wife who were caught up in, and key contributors to, the forces that were causing the older Puritanism to evolve into the newer evangelicalism? Or, should we also move from exposition to application and hold their marriage up as an exemplary model of partnership for modern ministry couples? Should we focus upon how Jonathan understood Sarah’s religious experiences and used them to advance his own spiritual agenda for New England? Or, was his love for Sarah near the heart of his theology, second only to his love for God? It seems there is some truth in each of these interpretations. It also seems none of them alone provides an adequate account of the Edwardses’ uncommon union. And what are we to make of their commitment to human enslavement during nearly the entirety of their marriage?
I would suggest that the time is ripe for some intrepid doctoral student to devote a dissertation to a fresh take on Jonathan and Sarah’s marriage. How were they illustrative of other ministerial marriages among New England Puritans? What about the wider transatlantic Reformed tradition? Other than Jonathan being an intellectual polymath and writing rapturous short treatises about his wife, was anything else unique about their marriage? Did their marriage influence other marriages among writers in the Edwardsean tradition as it evolved into the New Divinity and New Haven traditions?
For those interested more in a good seminar paper than a dissertation topic, some related topics that might not be fully worthy of a dissertation include fresh studies on Jonathan and Sarah’s approach to parenting and how they conceived of their household. Perhaps this essay will inspire grist for some budding historian’s mill. For now, I think we can say with certainty that, somewhat unlike Jonathan’s contemporaries Whitefield and John Wesley, but more like Martin and Katie Luther from an earlier generation, the Edwardses’ marriage was filled with deep affections—both of the romantic kind and the spiritual, dare I say, even Edwardsean variety. And in that way, at least, they are worth emulating.