Introduction1
In 1909 American Presbyterian missionary to Iran, Howard Baskerville, resigned his teaching post in Tabriz, Iran to fight for Iranians warring against governmental troops during the Constitutional Revolution.2 He died at 24 years old. His death proved impactful for Christianity in Iran and Iranian/American relations. In 1975, in a paper presented for the Bicentennial Celebrations of American Independence at Pahlavi University in Shiraz, Iran, politician Ali Pasha Saleh praised American missionaries and called the United States the hero of freedom in Iran. Saleh connected the Constitutional Revolution with the American Revolution and described Baskerville as the “Lafayette of Iran.”3 As late as 2005, in Tabriz, the Islamic Republic of Iran, with then President Mohammed Khatami presiding, unveiled a bust of Baskerville.4 Over 100 years and two regime changes later, Iranians still love Baskerville. Baskerville serves as an example of a Christian who fought against the repressive and unbiblical policies of a government. Baskerville’s actions illuminate a question faced by many American evangelical Christians: when is there the biblical, moral, and ethical responsibility to violate a country’s laws?
While Baskerville is admired by Iranians for his sacrifice–including by Iranian Muslims today–this paper will argue that even though there is a biblical directive to disobey laws under certain circumstances, with regard to the current situation in Iran–specifically the mandate for females to wear the traditional Islamic dress, the manteau [knee length jacket] and rousari [headscarf]–Christians, including Iranian Christians in Iran, Christian missionaries to Iran, and American evangelicals, should not illegally protest or incite rebellion against the Iranian administration. Rebelling against the Iranian government in this case is not only unwise, but also unbiblical. Christians have given up their rights for the cause of Christ. Furthermore, foreign interference will only damage Christianity in Iran.
The Current Situation in Iran
Iran became an Islamic Republic in 1979 during a democratic (and largely bloodless) revolution that ushered out the Western-leaning, secular Islamic government of Mohammad Reza Shah and the Pahlavi Dynasty. Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini returned from exile in Europe to form a religious Islamic administration founded on a strict interpretation of the principles of Shiism–the ongoing state religion of Iran from roughly the time of the Reformation–a type of Islam whose adherents include less than 20 percent of Muslims worldwide but comprise about 90 percent of Muslims in Iran.5
Aside from political reasons–a relatively new declassified Central Intelligence Agency document reveals that Ayatollah Khomeini understood the need for American involvement in Iran as early as 19636–there were moral and religious motives for the revolution. Concerning female dress, the (in)famous phrase during Mohammad Reza Shah’s time that the “miniskirts in Tehran were shorter than the miniskirts in Paris”7 was something that Ayatollah Khomeini and his followers wanted to change; they saw this type of dress as sexually exploitive and degrading to women. Years before during the 1930s, under Reza Shah Pahlavi, Mohammad Reza Shah’s father enacted laws that prohibited women from wearing the traditional Islamic head covering.8 With the 1979 revolution, laws were introduced that revisited the dress code. At first, the manteau and rousari were required only for state business. A couple of years later, females were required to wear the traditional dress in all public places.9
The dress code has provoked ongoing debate. Not all Iranian leaders believed these changes were healthy. Even as late as 2012, the media adviser to then President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, Ali Akbar Javanfekrone, was sentenced to jail for supporting the lessening of restrictions on female dress (as reported by the government-sponsored Mehr News Agency).10 Indeed, as the title of one article suggests, at least with the head covering, “headcovers have always been political in Iran–for women on all sides.”11
Submission to Government
Romans 13 is a main text used when addressing submission to government. Using Romans 13 as his base, American pastor and theologian John Piper, in a four-part series titled, “Subjection to God and Subjection to the State,” explains that all regimes are selected by God and must be obeyed, including administrations that are evil. Piper uses Jeroboam in 1 Kings 12.15, Nebuchadnezzar in Jeremiah 27.6, and Pilate in John 19.10 as examples. In each case, the Lord was the one who put and kept the ruler in power.12 Piper gives four reasons from Romans 13 that a Christian should submit to government:
- All authority is ordained by God who ultimately is in control.
- Government is for the good of the people.
- Refusal to obey laws often means punishment.
- Failure to submit to government can mean violating the moral law of God.13
Paul, the author of Romans, whose emperor was Nero, a man not the kindest to Christians, stated bluntly that Christians should obey the laws of the land. Indeed, Jesus Christ in Matthew 5.38-48 states that one should love and pray for his enemies and not resist evil.14
That does not mean the Bible does not provide exceptions and support the breaking of laws. Daniel prayed to God after an official governmental edict that stated one could only pray to the king (Daniel 6.6-10); Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego did not bow to an idol (Daniel 3:9-18); the midwives did not kill the Hebrew newborn babies as commanded by Pharoah (Exodus 1:15-20); Queen Esther approached the king without permission to save her people (Esther 3-5); 15the Maji did not tell King Herod where the baby Jesus was located (Matthew 2:1-12); and Jesus and the disciples picked grain on the sabbath (Mark 2:23-28).16 These are some examples of where the Bible commends noncompliance against government. These citations do not include the multiple times where Scripture outright endorses the proclamation of the gospel over the edicts of the state. Indeed, biblical support for Christians disobeying government in some ways seems conventional.
The biblical citations mentioned above are examples of peaceful and non-violent actions against the laws of a country. This is often called “civil disobedience.” A natural outflow of civil disobedience is “just war.” Though not as clearly mandated in Scripture, just war theory has a long and storied heritage in the Western world, going back to writers such as Augustine of Hippo, Thomas Aquinas, and Hugo Grotius. Usually referred to when addressing two independent states, the criterion for just war could be applied in a broader sense, internally to Iranian Christians in Iran, externally to American missionaries to Iran and to American evangelicals in general. Several criteria of just war theory are relevant. The first is “just cause”: there must be a specific reason for going to war. A second criterion is “last resort”: all other nonviolent options must be pursued, such as civil disobedience. This implies also that all diplomatic efforts should continue to settle the grievances through negotiation rather than military or violent conflict. A third criterion is one of “right intention”: the intention must be to secure peace and civil order for all parties involved. This principle rules out conflicts for economic exploitation, or of national, religious, or ethnic cleansing. Finally, one should consider carefully the consequences that may flow from any intervention or violent acts. This concern is reflected in the criteria of probability of success and proportionality of projected results. Under these criteria, a war is not waged justly unless victory is likely and the good in achieving victory must be greater than the cost to achieve it. In the case of fighting for more relaxed female attire in Iran, non-peaceful actions internally or externally would not produce a clear or permanent triumph, especially since there have been variations of the dress code in Iran over the last one hundred years, and the dress code seems to be a political issue almost as much as if not more so than a civil rights one. Whatever victory was produced, it would not be greater than the cost to achieve it.17 Indeed, although Iran treats females differently than the West, and although Iran’s rhetoric and actions are sometimes considered aggressive, this does not provide just cause for illegal or outside intervention. The governmental requirement of dress for females does not meet any of these just war criteria.
God’s Gifts, the Great Commission and Great Commandment, and Idolatry
A point to remember when addressing the current situation in Iran and the requirement for females to wear the manteau and rousari is that whatever liberties Christians have–whether they be in Iran, America, or elsewhere–come first and foremost from God. They are gifts, not rights. God’s gifts do not need to be given. In God’s eyes, no one is entitled to them. Christians recognize that apart from God’s special grace – his gift of salvation – they are God haters, condemned to spend eternity in hell paying for their sins. God’s gifts are for his purposes – namely, to spread his glory through Christ by the Great Commission (Matthew 28:18-20) and the Great Commandment (Matthew 22:37-40). Christians’ time, money, and effort are (or should be) spent on deepening their relationships with Christ and making the gospel known to people from all tribes, languages, and nations (Revelation 5:9 and 7:9), not fighting governmental policies about attire.
When Christians pursue God’s gifts over God himself, they make his gifts into idols. As late American pastor Tim Keller explains, an idol is “anything more important to you than God … If I have that [whatever ‘that’ may be] I’ll feel my life has meaning, then I’ll know I have value, then I’ll feel significant and secure.”18 When a “political or social cause [of] making progress and ascending in influence or power” gives life meaning, Keller writes, the goodness of helping and/or persuading others becomes an idol.19 When Christians feel so strongly about God’s gifts that they take the place in their hearts of where only God should be–if God’s gifts give meaning to life or give one hope outside of God’s grace alone, intentionally or unintentionally–they become idols. Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s famous invitation comes to mind: “When Christ calls a man, he bids him [to] come and die.”20 Famous early church father Tertullian’s reported words arise as well: “The blood of the martyrs is the seed of the church.”21 More importantly, Scripture states that being a Christian means one will suffer. Second Timothy 3:12 asserts that “Everyone who wants to live godly in Christ Jesus will be persecuted.” First Peter 4:16 declares that Christians should not be ashamed to suffer for Christ. Philippians 1:29 indicates that suffering for Christ is a gift of God.22 Even if the manteau and rousari are restrictive towards women, including Christian women in Iran (and not all Christian women in Iran feel this way), could this be a cross they should bear joyfully, only dissent legally, and instead focus on other more harmful and unbiblical acts of government? Similarly, should not American missionaries to Iran and American evangelicals do the same?
The Complicated History of Christian Missionary Involvement in Iran
Western missionary activity in Iran has a convoluted story. Missionaries brought the gospel with them to Iran, but much more, especially with their governmental connections. Bishop H. B. Dehqani-Tafti–the Martin Luther of Iranian Christianity and the first Anglican bishop of Persian origin–who collaborated with Western missionaries and vigorously defended them, asserted that although the missionaries’ connection with the Iranian administration during Pahlavi times allowed them to do good for Iranians, it brought a stigma of foreignness to Christianity. This stigma, he believes, hindered the growth of the Iranian church. If American missionaries depend on government, Dehqani-Tafti asked, how does the message of the gospel translate? Trusting in the state becomes a poor Christian witness.23 Dehqani-Tafti is strong in his condemnation:
Unfortunately not always have missionaries been able, even consciously, to completely separate themselves from the economic and political and sometimes military force of their own government. And this is sometimes almost impossible to do–because if you separate yourself artificially you become a hypocrite.
But the message of Christianity is meekness and humility; it’s giving your life for your enemy; if this is the core of the Christian message–and I believe it is–now how on earth can you present this in the shape of power? and influence? and money? and grandeur? This is the dilemma.
So Christianity ought not to be packages of denominations or groups in a corner; it ought to be dissolved into society. We are part and parcel of our nation, it doesn’t matter if we have identities or rights or boundaries or land or associations or organizations; what matters is whether Christian individuals have the spirit of Christ–the spirit of the cross–in them wherever they are.24
Iranian Christian leader and academic Sasan Tavassoli, too, recognizes some of the disadvantages of Western missionaries in Iran during Pahlavi times. His quote of Isabel Stumpel-Hatami, an Iranian Muslim who addressed the Iranian Muslim perception of Christianity in Iran during the modern era, typifies the sentiment that Westernizing people often was confused with cross-cultural evangelism, the issue that Tavassoli seems to imply was a hindrance for Iranian interest in Christianity.25 According to Tavassoli, Stumpel-Hatami states:
Due to Western colonialists and missionary activities Christianity is thus identified with the Occident…. The manifold activities deployed by occidental missionaries through educational and medical assistance in schools, hospitals, summer camps, youth clubs, and bookstores and through the modern mass media did not prosper without provoking the deep concern and the protest of the religious class. The more the Christian mission was organized, the more it appeared to them like an ever-growing network of conspiracy.26
Among other Iranian Muslims, Jalal al-Ahmad’s Occidentosis,27 while not the most historically accurate piece, showed similar concerns Iranians had with Western missionaries. He believed that Muslims have been at war with Christians for over 1000 years and equated Christianity with colonialism, and saw Christians as servants of government, calling the missionaries the “vanguard of colonialism” and colonialism the “equivalent of Christianity.” Similarly, Ayatollah Khomeini, in Islam and Revolution, condemned much of what he saw as the Shah’s capitulation to Westernization, which was personified in the Shah’s edict in 1964 that stated American governmental officials were immune from prosecution.28
To a degree both al-Ahmad and Ayatollah Khomeini are correct. As Protestant missions increased, colonialism among Protestant nations increased. This rise is particularly clear in the High Imperial Era, when governmental representatives praised the work of missionaries. A painting entitled The Secret of England’s Greatness,29 which depicts Queen Victoria giving a Bible to an African tribesman, suggests the connection between government and religion. As late as the 1950s, the overt connection between Western missionaries and government was lauded.30 It is not a coincidence that Christian missionaries’ global influence grew with the rise of Western nations.31
Some Reminders32
Understanding these realities, and appreciating that Iranians have a “public face” and a “private face,” are helpful for American Christians thinking about being involved in Iran’s internal affairs. Recognizing this variation, and realizing that the two sometimes conflict, is one key to grasping Iranians and their culture. Hooman Majd, an Iranian-American journalist whose pieces on Iran appear in GQ, The New Yorker, The New York Times, and The New York Observer, surmises that leadership in the Islamic Republic is conscious of this difference. The Muslim, Iranian government (public face), democratically ushered into power over 40 years ago, prohibits (among other things) alcohol consumption, premarital sex, and dancing, though all these things happen inside Iranians’ homes (private face).33 Another example of the public/private interface is how Iranians view the United States. While many Iranian Muslim religious leaders do not like America because of the United States-engineered coup that overthrew the popularly elected leader Mohammad Mosaddeq and replaced him with the Shah in 1953,34 many Iranians, when confronted personally (private face) about their feelings toward the United States, have a positive attitude even though they openly (public face) protest against America in the streets. Often, they have a problem with the American government (public face) and not necessarily with the American people (private face).35
Additionally, appreciating the concepts of haq and ta’arouf, two essential yet seemingly paradoxical traditions, are important. Haq is the idea of ‘unalienable’ rights, while ta’arouf is the idea of self-depreciation. Iranians believe they have certain haq; one of those is equality. Majd explains that Iranians desire to be treated as equals:
The question of rights is fundamental to Shi’a Islam, the very founding of which was a struggle for rightfulness. And Shi’a Iran, with a history of centuries of perceived injustice towards its religion and sect, and the trampling of its sovereignty by foreign powers, cannot easily accept any attempt to deprive its people of their rights. The sense of rights and justice is so deeply ingrained in the Iranian psyche that when Iranians mourn Imams martyred fourteen hundred years ago, as they do during the month of Moharram, they are consumed by paroxysms of weeping, not necessarily for the dead, but for the cruel injustice perpetrated on their saints and, by extension, on them still today.36
At present, haq seems noticeable around the appropriate legal attire for Iranian women. In understanding haq, and the natural outflows of it, Christian missionaries to Iran and American evangelicals should understand why the question of dress is an internal matter to Iranians.
Ta’arouf, or extreme southern United States hospitality, also pervades Iranian culture. It is an attempt at self-depreciation in which the person who humbles himself the most gains an advantage; it is “passive-aggressive behavior with a peculiarly Persian hue.”37 Ta’arouf occurs throughout Iranian life. Often, what one says is not what one means; one is just being respectful. For example, in a business transaction, the seller might tell the buyer the item is for free or is not worth much, though obviously (or not so obviously) the seller does not mean this. In fact, the exact opposite may be the truth. It is the seller’s way of allowing both parties to save face and come to an agreed upon price. Being able to save face, especially in public, is important in Iranian culture.
Ta’arouf does not occur only among Iranians in their own culture; Iranians practice it internationally. A vivid example of ta’arouf is the interpretation of Majd’s friend, Faud, a Jewish-Iranian from Los Angeles, of former Iranian President Ahmadinejad’s rejection of the Jewish Holocaust. Majd describes Faud’s reasoning for Ahmadinejad’s denial: Ahmadinejad (sarcastically) is saying that he could not believe that Europeans, with their “great” and “mighty” civilization, could act in such a barbaric manner. In questioning the need for the creation of Israel, Ahmadinejad was implying that Europeans (Germans specifically) were capable of another genocide, though, ironically, Europeans (and Americans) were accusing Ahmadinejad and the leadership of the Islamic Republic of the very same thing with the very same people.38 Regarding female dress and the protests in Iran, something similar with ta’arouf might be thought. Evangelicals from the United States whose “Christian” government in the past has promoted civil rights abuses and racial inequality then taking moral high ground regarding Iran’s laws about female clothing seems a bit ironic.
The Iranian government has not been able to find a solution that pleases everyone inside Iran regarding the manteau and rousari, which has led to some extreme acts. Understanding how haq and ta’arouf permeate Iranian culture should help American evangelicals and missionaries to Iran grasp a simple fact. Depending on the circumstance, Iranians filter their thoughts and actions through different grids in their minds, which – from an outsider’s view, particularly a Westerner’s – seem inconsistent and contradictory. Therefore, caution should be advised when commenting on Iran’s edicts surrounding dress.
Conclusion
The relationship between Iranian governments and Iranian Christians has vacillated between tension and comfort. When outside forces arrive or a major threat occurs, there is a disruption in the arrangement between Iranian Christians and the ruling Iranian governments, for better and for worse. Contemporary Iranian policies may be illuminated by examining the effects of outside forces on historical Iranian governments, and such governments’ reactions to those threats in terms of providing and withdrawing freedoms. The leaders of the Islamic Republic hope to promote the success of their country, and because the West, in general, and the United States, in particular, are considered to be Christian and have a history of meddling in Iran’s internal affairs,
Iran’s current hostility to any deviation from the limitations placed upon Christians in Iran (and society in general), while inappropriate, is understandable.
Indeed, Iranian Christians are now not only considered apostates, but threats to national security.39 From the perspective of the Islamic Republic authorities, there is something insurgent about Iranian Christians who do not follow the restrictions placed upon them, because they are thereby rejecting the ideology of the Islamic Republic. Theologian Marcin Rzepka addresses this rationale:
When discussing their [Iranian Christian converts from Muslim backgrounds] motivations for conversion, the converts emphasize their disappointment with Islam. Thus, they try to escape from politicized Islam, or from radical interpretations of it made by Khomeini and his followers. In this sense, Islam becomes something inauthentic and at the same time oppressive in the converts’ eyes, which strongly contrasts with Christianity, which insists on the imperative of love, even for one’s enemies.40
However, Christian acts of love are not always apparent. Sometimes Christians behave like non-Christians. Mahatma Gandhi reportedly stated he would have been a Christian if it were not for Christians.41 Christians’ ultimate authority–the Bible–commands in Ephesians 4:15 that Christians speak the truth in love. While more challenging in certain environments, an atmosphere that fosters speech which reflects the truths of Scripture, in the spirit of Jesus Christ, understands the nuances of different viewpoints, and acts justly with sympathy when discussing them allows the opportunity for issues to be addressed in a truthful, peaceful, and accurate manner. Being thankful for the gifts God has given is honoring and admirable; making God’s gifts into idols and coveting gifts God has not given are not. Therefore, American evangelicals and Christian missionaries to Iran getting involved in what the Iranian administration allows females to wear, including making ‘innocuous’ posts on social media, seem to fuel the negative and (sometimes) incorrect perceptions Iranians already have of Christianity and Americans, and thus prove to be a hinderance to the gospel.
The question is not whether Iranian females should have the freedom of choice to wear whatever they want. The question also is not whether Christians in Iran or Christian missionaries to Iran should be able to protest, or even if American evangelicals should get involved in Iran’s internal affairs. Rather, the question concerns at what point does noncompliance against the state become biblically warranted. The Iranian government not giving females the choice to wear or not to wear the manteau and rousari is not sin.
Though it is generally agreed among Christians that 1 Corinthians 11:2-16 was cultural for the time, Scripture itself has supported head coverings for females. Other biblical passages such as Deuteronomy 22:5, 1 Timothy 2:9-10, and 1 Peter 3:3-5 also stress that females should dress modestly. For Christians then to state the Iranian government is acting unbiblically when it requires women to wear the manteau and rousari seems insincere.
Scripture does not provide a defined set of instructions as to when noncompliance against the state is permitted. The seriousness, magnitude, and degree of the offense, combined with the ability for transparent and real change, should be considered before any acts are committed. When Christians contravene laws, they must do so out of love–love even for the opposition–and the desire for justice to be accomplished as much as possible in a non-violent and peaceful manner.42
Currently, one can look to Iranian Christians as an example of what can be done with a government that opposes Christ and restricts choices. Iranian Christianity is one without religious liberty, but it has flourished. The example of Christians in Iran indicates that relying on government or other forces outside of God himself to sustain and protect Christianity and the freedoms that come with it is not wise. Regarding the manteau and rousari, American evangelicals should remember their own country’s failings, and not illegally try to change or influence non-antibiblical laws of another country – like Iran’s dress code for women.