Book Review: Leadership in Ukraine: Studies During Wartime

By Jason Palmer

Alexander I. Negrov (PhD, University of Pretoria) is a theologian and leadership scholar who hails from Ukraine and resides in Washington State. He is president and founder of Hodos Institute, a cross-cultural research and training organization with operations in the United States and Ukraine. Since the publication of Leadership in Ukraine, the Eastern European Institute of Theology, in Lviv, has designated him a Senior Research Fellow. Ronald E. Riggio (PhD, University of California, Riverside) is a leadership scholar and organizational psychologist serving as Henry R. Kravis Professor of Leadership and Organizational Psychology at Claremont McKenna College in Claremont, California. This collaborative endeavor contributes an intriguing collection of mostly qualitative research exploring Ukrainian perspectives on leadership amid Russia’s protracted military campaign.

The authors appear to concentrate their appeal to Western scholars on the hope that this book “will be useful to those who dedicate their efforts to standing with Ukrainians in the years to come” (p. 3). More than a general survey of leadership trends in Ukraine, most of the aggregated studies showcase the perspectives of a minority demographic in the country’s religious tapestry: evangelical Christians. This unique angle renders the publication keenly attractive to academics researching in the field of Christian leadership. Negrov and Riggio proffer a clarion thesis: that war—and more narrowly Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine that commenced on February 24, 2022—has yielded an observable impact on perspectives regarding leadership in Ukraine. They substantiate this assertion using a series of research initiatives that prioritize phenomenological and ethnographic methodologies to better understand the lived experiences of individuals and the shared experiences of groups.

The content is divided into eight chapters. Chapter 1 traces the historical and cultural origins of the present crisis and outlines the competing Russian and Ukrainian narratives that preceded Russia’s annexation of Crimea in 2014. The authors begin to answer the question What does leadership in wartime look like? by laying solid groundwork for their determination that Ukrainian preferences have noticeably shifted from a historic penchant for strong, charismatic leaders to an affinity for “distributed leadership structures” that increasingly normalize shared leadership (p. 14). That groundwork continues in chapter 2 through excerpts of interviews with seasoned organizational leaders and college students—many of them self-identifying as Christians—that were conducted from 2015 to 2017.

Chapter 3 investigates the perspectives of Ukrainian Christian adolescents from September 2018 until March 2019 through an approach involving a mixture of qualitative (interviews and survey groups) and quantitative (surveys) methods. Along the way, another prominent claim of the book emerges: the authors’ evidence contradicts some unfavorable assumptions commonly held by Ukrainian adults about young people in their society. Chapter 4 suggests some general conclusions about leadership in Ukraine through interviews with forty-five Ukrainian organizational and community leaders from March 2022 to May 2022. The writers use this opportunity to propose conceptualizations of exemplary leadership by reviewing several contemporary models: transformational leadership, Leader-Member Exchange theory, servant leadership, and authentic leadership. The way the authors define exemplary leadership proves critical to their overall case as this concept resurfaces regularly in the succeeding chapters.

Chapter 5 responds to a gap of understanding regarding “how Ukrainians forced into displacement exhibit leadership within the context of war,” utilizing the results of 130 online surveys completed from April 2022 to August 2022 by Ukrainian Christian war refugees spread across twenty-four countries (p. 78). The collected data contribute to a trauma-sensitive theology of leadership. Chapter 6 compiles insights from a diverse group of 257 participants gathered during various learning events between September 2022 and February 2023. Chapter 7 gleans the input of sixty organizational leaders, sixty percent of whom hold graduate degrees. Final conclusions are articulated in chapter 8, among which is the finding that “leadership in Ukraine is evolving into a more inclusive, participatory model…characterized by adaptability, emotional and psychological support, and a deep sense of responsibility toward the nation and its people” (p. 146).

The authors establish an unapologetically pro-Ukrainian stance from the opening pages and maintain that interpretive posture unwaveringly throughout the book’s characterization of data, as well as the associated findings and conclusions. The authors do not mask their solidarity with the Ukrainian people, and they convey a sincere “hope that many Ukrainians will eventually not only withstand the trauma of war but also grow and thrive through that trauma” (p. 15). Beyond a vague sentiment of good will, this research could be described as an “active engagement” in the ongoing “information war” by contributing an intellectual, pro-Ukrainian counternarrative to Russia’s strategic messaging crusade (pp. 64, 102).

Current Ukrainian perceptions on leadership during large-scale combat operations against a larger regional aggressor—especially the experiences of evangelical Christians—is the distinct emphasis of this monograph. As such, the authors’ advocacy for shared leadership and dismissal of “the outdated idea of top-down, authoritarian leadership” would have benefitted from the inclusion of research exploring the leadership perceptions of servicemembers from the Armed Forces of Ukraine (p. 130). Without the inclusion of Ukrainian active duty and veteran voices speaking directly to the need for command-and-control expressions of leadership in certain contexts, arguments against both the prevalence and potential value of such brands of leadership seem less than fully orbed. Engaging any combination of commissioned and voluntary Ukrainian military chaplains might have more comprehensively corroborated the shift in leadership perspectives and constituted a natural point of convergence between the field of leadership and the Christian community.

The authors provide a limited treatment of contemporary leadership theories without clear explanation as to why they highlight certain theories and omit others. The selected leadership theories they introduce are not examined critically but seem to be accompanied by a tacit assumption of theological compatibility with Christian orthodoxy, despite those theories lacking any meaningful Christology and even including elements that many Christ-followers find anthropologically problematic. Given the level of attention that this research gives to the evangelical Christian community in Ukraine and dispersed abroad, the researchers’ findings would have been even more helpful if delivered with additional consideration to the intersection of Christian theology and popular leadership theory.

All in all, Leadership in Ukraine offers a valuable contribution to the field of Christian leadership by probing a lingering conflict that has captured global interest. While framed for an academic audience, Negrov and Riggio’s volume deserves examination by a broader audience. Chief among these are ministry practitioners who will find themselves invited to inquire about the leadership trends among the various groups in their area of influence—especially those negotiating crises of various types.