For four centuries, biblical scholars have diligently unlearned how to read the Bible, training themselves to see the trees but never the forest. In Old Testament studies especially, critical scholars rejected not only the Divine authorship of Scripture, but almost every traditional attribution of human authorship in favor of the Documentary Hypothesis. The Documentary Hypothesis atomized the books of the Old Testament into isolated fragments and envisioned ancient editors who stitched mysterious sources together like an analog cut-and-paste project. Many Evangelical scholars clung to biblical authority, but nevertheless followed some of the same methods of interpretation, showing little appreciation for the unity of the biblical books, their literary brilliance, or the reliance of later authors upon earlier authors. Biblical interpretation resembled dissection rather than reading. Each tree could be labelled by genus and species and its scientific processes described, but we dare not stand in awe of the forest in which each tree lives, fearing that we might lose our scientific objectivity. However, as in the forest, the narratives and teachings of Scripture live in beautiful symbiotic relationships with one another rather than in laboratory isolation. Biblical scholarship grounded in faith seeks to stand in awe, beholding the unity, mutual dependence, and breathtaking beauty of the trees set within the living forest of God’s revelation.
In telling the story of Israel between the conquest and the monarchy, the author of Judges saw his narrative as symbiotically connected to the story of Genesis. Even first-time readers of the Bible notice the allusion to the sin of Sodom when reading about the sin of the men of Gibeah in Judges 19 (cf. Gen 19:1–11). In both instances, the men of the city violate the most minimal standards of hospitality by demanding to rape male guests, and in both instances, women are offered up as substitute rape victims. Although in Genesis the two messengers rescued Lot’s daughters from victimization, in Judges the men of Gibeah rape a woman to death. By reworking the Sodom story, Judges presents Israel without a king as more wicked than cities justly destroyed by fire from heaven.
While the narrative analogy between Judges 19 and Genesis 19 is quite obvious, many other allusions and analogies exist between the two books.1 In the Abimelech narrative of Judges 9, the author presents Abimelech and his imposter kingdom as a foil to the Abrahamic promise given in Genesis 12.2 Judges makes an immediate connection between the two narratives through a shared setting—the city of Shechem with its great tree or trees—which highlights the larger thematic resonance between the narratives: covenant, kingdom, and presence. In light of the Abrahamic promise in Genesis 12, Judges demonstrates Abimelech’s kingdom to be a failed attempt to establish a kingdom in Israel apart from Yahweh. This narrative tree can only be adequately understood when considering it in relation to the forest in which it lives.
The Great Tree in Genesis
In Genesis, the great tree at Shechem echoes Eden and thus points forward to a promised kingdom that will restore humanity’s relationship with God. While only mentioned twice, the oak, terebinth, or great tree (אֵלוֹן) at Shechem unites two patriarchal narratives that emphasize the themes of covenant, kingdom, and presence (Gen 12:6; 35:8).
A New Eden
Yahweh walked with Adam amid the arboreal garden in Eden, but Adam sinned and hid “from the face of Yahweh Elohim among the trees of the garden” (Gen 3:8). As the wickedness of man increased on the earth, Yahweh resolved to destroy humanity but chose Noah to rescue a remnant. After receiving confirmation that Yahweh had again caused trees to grow on the earth (Gen 8:11), Noah disembarked, receiving the commission of a new Adam in a new creation (Gen 8:20–9:17). Like Adam, Noah became a farmer. Like Adam, Noah sinfully took of the fruit of his garden and exposed his nakedness, and like Adam, he died (Gen 9:18–28).
Yet despite Noah’s sin, God intended a restoration of his fellowship with humanity. Following the scattering of the nations at Babel, Yahweh chose Abram and promised to establish his kingdom through Abram. Yahweh promised Abram that he would become a great nation in the land Yahweh would show him, that he would be blessed, and that his name would be made great (Gen 12:1–2), and then through the fulfillment of these promises, blessing would extend to all the families of the earth (Gen 12:3). With each element of the promise, Yahweh was pledging to establish a global kingdom through the childless man from Ur. Peter Gentry notes specifically the significance of the promise to make from Abram a גוֹי גָּדוֹל (“great nation”). While normally we think of the non-Israelite nations as the גוֹיִם, Gentry explains:
The basic meaning of gôy is an organized community of people having governmental, political, and social structure. The word contrasts with the derogatory term for the other nations, mišpāhâ, in Genesis 12. This word refers to an amorphous kin group larger than an extended family and smaller than a tribe.3
Yahweh did not merely promise Abram a family or a land but a kingdom that would encompass all peoples. Within the context of Genesis, this global kingdom signifies the promise of a new creation, a new beginning for humanity when they will finally “be fruitful and multiply and fill the earth and subdue it and have dominion” (Gen 1:28). Therefore, having received the promise, Abram follows Yahweh to the land of Canaan and immediately passes through the land to its geographical center, the city of Shechem. At Shechem, he comes to the “great tree of Moreh,” and there “Yahweh appeared to Abram” (Gen 12:6–7; cf. Deut 11:30). Three elements in Genesis 12:6–7 identify the promised land as the new Eden: First, the great tree that alludes to the trees of Eden and possibly even to the tree of life; second, the appearance of Yahweh (possibly the first since Eden depending on what is meant by Enoch’s experience of walking with God; Gen 5:22);4 and third, the priestly service of building an altar, which reflects Adam’s priestlike service in the garden (Gen 2:15).5
Historically, readers are left with many questions about the “great tree of Moreh.” Does אֵלוֹן denote a specific species such as an oak or terebinth, or does it simply indicate a great tree regardless of species? Why was this great tree associated with מוֹרֶה? Does מוֹרֶה mean “teacher” in this instance, does it point to a pagan practice such as divination, or is it a proper name? What sort of pagan rites might have taken place at such a sacred tree and why would a worshiper of Yahweh identify the great tree as an appropriate place of worship?6 Most of these historical questions can never be answered adequately. Nevertheless, readers may understand the literary significance of the “great tree of Moreh.” Wenham points out the consonance between מוֹרֶה and Yahweh’s appearing (יֵרָה), which emphasizes Abram’s unique experience of Yahweh’s presence at the tree.7 While the word for tree in Genesis 2–3 is the more general term עֵץ, the thematic significance of Yahweh appearing beside a great tree to a king-priest gives a glimpse of the fulfillment of the promise he gave Abram—a global kingdom of blessing that restores Eden-like fellowship with Yahweh.
A Failed Conquest
Readers encounter the great tree at Shechem again in Genesis 35. The defilement of Dinah and its aftermath threatened to extinguish the promise given to Abraham (Gen 34). Would the family line of Abraham simply be absorbed into the Canaanites with Jacob’s children intermarrying with the people of Shechem and becoming “one people” with them (Gen 34:16)? Simeon and Levi, despite the folly of their behavior, rescued the Abrahamic line from being absorbed into the Shechemites. Their actions foreshadowed the conquest of Canaan, but Jacob’s response highlighted two reasons why the time was not yet right for the conquest of the land. First, Jacob lamented their numerical deficiency. They were too few to fight the Canaanites (Gen 34:30–31). But secondly, Jacob identified the spiritual deficiency of his family. They were not wholly devoted to Yahweh (Gen 35:1–4).
Following the slaughter of Shechem, God reaffirmed the Abrahamic promise to Jacob by commanding him to go to Bethel and build an altar there. In this reaffirmation, Moses alluded to the earlier altars built by Abraham first at Shechem where Yahweh appeared and then at Bethel where Abraham settled (Gen 12:6–8). Jacob’s experience, however, followed an inverse ordering from his grandfather. God had already appeared to him at Bethel during his flight from Esau, and now he must go and build an altar there (Gen 28:10–22).8 But going to “God’s house” (בֵית־אֵל) to offer priestly worship required purification (cf. Exod 29:4–9), both the physical purification of bathing and changing clothes and the spiritual purification of removing idols and amulets. We read that “Jacob buried these things under the great tree near Shechem” (Gen 35:4). Since this is the site where Yahweh had first appeared to Abraham, Jacob may have seen this act as a means of stripping the objects of their power, but why not break or burn them as we see others doing as an act of repentance (e.g., Exod 32:20; 2 Kings 23:4–15)? Alternatively, due the association of the great tree with the trees of Eden, he may have viewed the depositing of idols as akin to returning the fruit of rebellion to the tree, an act of repentance and renewal of relations with Yahweh as the only true God. Regardless of the significance of the burial, Jacob’s actions foreshadow the command of Joshua in the same location to “put away your fathers’ gods” (Josh 24:14).9
Summary of the Tree in Genesis
Genesis identifies Shechem and particularly the great tree at Shechem as a location where the fulfillment of the Abrahamic promise is foreshadowed. At the great tree, Abraham saw God, and Jacob repented of his foreign gods. Through his covenant with this family line, Yahweh promises to re-establish a global kingdom where humanity will dwell with God as his people and experience blessing. To bring about the fulfillment of the promise will require the eradication of the Canaanites and their gods, but first the descendants of Abraham must purify themselves and repent of their own rebellion. Only after the purification of the people, initiated by Jacob’s actions at Shechem, can the promise be confirmed and ultimately fulfilled to Israel.
The Background and Setting of the Abimelech Narrative
“In those days there was no king in Israel, and each man did what was right in his own eyes” (Judg 21:25). According to Judges, the establishment of a monarch would resolve the downward spiral of sin experienced by post-conquest Israel. Yet the Gideon-Abimelech narrative demonstrates that not any king would do. Only a Deuteronomy 17-type king who is devoted to the law of Yahweh can lead Israel to establish God’s global kingdom where God would dwell with his covenant people. A false kingdom built upon a broken covenant could only bring about alienation from and enmity with Yahweh.
Gideon’s False-Rejection of the Monarchy
Following Gideon’s miraculous victory over the Midianites, Israel implores him to establish a dynasty to rule over Israel (Judg 8:22). Gideon’s response reflects Israel’s own fickle commitment to Yahweh. While he refuses the monarchy, saying “Yahweh will rule over you” (Judg 8:23; cf. 1 Sam 8:7), he nevertheless acts as a pagan king.10 Deuteronomy 17:17 warns that the king of Israel “shall not take many wives for himself, lest his heart turn away, nor shall he take for himself excessive silver and gold.” Immediately upon rejecting the kingdom, Gideon sets forth to collect the gold of Israel, confirming his superior rank,11 and like Aaron, to fashion it into an object of worship (Judg 8:24–27; Exod 32:2–4). The form of the idol itself demonstrates the syncretistic nature of Yahweh worship during the time of the judges—a golden ephod.12 The garment of the priests of Yahweh is now turned into an object of worship. Jerubbaal may have contended with Baal, but he embraces idolatry nevertheless (Judg 6:28–32). Furthermore, he engages in the prolific polygamy that marked Ancient Near Eastern monarchy and that Deuteronomy forbade (Judg 8:29–31).
The climactic—or anti-climactic—mark of Gideon’s false rejection of monarchy is the naming of his son through a Shechemite concubine— אֲבִימֶלֶךְ or “my father is king.” At Shechem, Israel said to Joshua, “We will serve Yahweh, for he is our God” (Josh 24:18), and there under the great tree Joshua erected a stone monument saying, “Behold, this stone shall be a witness against us, for it has heard all the words of Yahweh that he spoke to us” (Josh 24:27). In his own person, Gideon is the embodiment of Israel’s faithlessness, saying one thing but doing another, but also like Israel, Gideon’s faithlessness will not go unnoticed by Yahweh.
The Tree at Shechem Again
The birth of My-Father-is-King (Abimelech) at Shechem, where Joshua had renewed the covenant with Israel, gives readers the initial indication that the narratives of Gideon and Abimelech speak not just about these specific historical events but ultimately to the entire history of Israel. One might even be tempted to say with Paul, “These things are allegorical” (ἅτινά ἐστιν ἀλληγορούμενα; Gal 4:24).13 Both Gideon’s initial false-rejection of the kingdom and Abimelech’s seizure of it demonstrate an Adam-like attempt to rule apart from Yahweh’s covenant and presence.
After slaughtering his brothers—an inwardly twisted act of conquest—“all the baalim (lords) of Shechem” (כָּל־בַּעֲלֵי שְׁכֶם) made Abimelech king “by the great tree of the propped-up thing at Shechem” (עִם־אֵלוֹן מֻצָּב אֲשֶׁר בִּשְׁכֶם; Judg 9:6). Jerubbaal may have contended with Baal, but now the baalim or lords of Shechem anoint his illegitimate son king. By describing the leaders of Shechem as בַּעֲלֵי שְׁכֶם, the author utilizes a technical term for covenantal partners, which is used for Abram’s allies in Genesis 14:13, while simultaneously emphasizing the unfaithfulness of the Shechemites.14 While Gideon had told Israel that Yahweh would rule over them, the little baalim of Shechem install his son as king instead and even hire his band of rogues with money from Baal-berith’s temple.
Most translations describe the location of this event as “the oak of the pillar at Shechem” (ESV; similarly, NIV, CSB). Barry G. Webb, however, translates the phrase as “the oak which had been set up” and speculates that the phrase could refer to a stone monument carved to look like a tree or a real tree planted with a particular significance.15 The most obvious identification of this tree, however, comes from Joshua 24:26, where Joshua erected a stone of witness “under the great tree” at Shechem. While the verb for “raising” is different between Joshua 24 (קום) and Judges 9 (נצב), the shared location, actions, and themes of the two chapters make the identification quite clear.16 Rather than translating it “the oak of the pillar,” it would be accurate to translate it as “the great tree of the raised [stone].” This seemingly minor detail reminds the reader that all these events occur before a silent witness to Israel’s unfaithfulness to Yahweh.17
A Broken Covenant, a Failed Kingdom, and an Absent God
Jotham’s fable (Judg 9:7–21) serves as the interpretive key for the entire series of events, but before examining the fable’s interpretation, the history of Abimelech’s reign should be reviewed.
A Failed Kingdom
Abimelech ruled as king for three years until God sent an evil spirit to disrupt the alliance between Abimelech and the little baalim of Shechem (Judg 9:22). Betraying Abimelech, the baalim shift their allegiance to Gaal the son of Ebed, an inebriated fool,18 but Abimelech, being warned by Zebul the ruler of Shechem, sets out to ambush Gaal and his allies. According to Gaal, the ambush came “from the way of the great tree of divination” (מִדֶּרֶךְ אֵלוֹן מְעוֹנְנִים).19 This sounds similar to the teacher’s tree of Abraham’s day, which may have always been rightly called the diviners’ tree because of the pagan practices associated with such sacred groves.20 Yet the degradation of the tree’s name in Judges may further signify the degradation of Israel and its own participation in the forbidden practice of divination (Lev 19:26; 20:6; Deut 18:9–14).
Is the diviners’ tree the same as the “great tree of the propped-up thing” in Judges 9:6? Some commentators believe these two trees are not the same,21 but there is little reason not to identify the great tree as the same tree in every instance: the tree where Yahweh appeared to Abraham is the tree where Jacob buried the idols, which is the tree where Joshua erected the stone witness and is the tree where Abimelech was crowned.22 The change in reference from “the great tree of the raised stone” to the “diviners’ tree” allows the author of Judges to emphasize the association of the tree with both Joshua and Abraham. Yet, if we cannot convince “beyond a reasonable doubt” that this great tree is historically one tree, we may nevertheless argue that in terms of literary allusion the idea of a “great tree at Shechem” links all these events together in the grander narrative of Israel’s history. Thus, the failure of Abimelech’s kingdom is set in juxtaposition to the promise of Yahweh’s global kingdom to Abraham.
A Broken Covenant
Following the initial defeat of Gaal and his band, probably thinking the crisis had passed, the people of Shechem again went out to their fields only to be slaughtered by Abimelech and his forces. Apparently, while the peasants attempted to work the fields, the baalim sought refuge in “the stronghold of the house of El-berith,” which likely is the same structure as “the tower of Shechem” (Judg 9:46).23 While this could refer to a structure separate from the city, it is likely that these events occurred on the acropolis of Shechem, which has been excavated and shows signs of destruction consistent with Judges 9.24
In Judges 8:33, the author tells us that following Gideon’s death Israel had made Baal-berith, or Baal of the Covenant, their god. Here in 9:46 the god is identified as El of the Covenant. It is unlikely that the change in nomenclature is insignificant. Some scholars have opted to identify the god as Baal identified by the epithet “god (el) of the covenant” while others have argued that the god of Shechem was El who was worshiped as the “lord (baal) of the covenant.”25 Lewis argues that the covenant god of Shechem, likely originating as the witness of a political treaty, later developed into the monolatrous El or Elohim of the Israelites and finally into Yahweh who made a covenant with his people.26 But the purpose of Judges leads us to read this development not in terms of evolution but devolution. The confusion of names and titles reflect the spiritual confusion of Israel and its process of Canaanization.27 Perhaps a memory of Abraham at Shechem and/or the renewal of the covenant under Joshua and the significance of the witness stone under the great tree came to be fused with the Canaanite gods that Israel whored after, and maybe it is a highlight of the spiritual confusion that the Israelites could not even agree on which false god was the god of the covenant—El or Baal. No matter whom the Shechemites identified as the god of the covenant, Judges makes clear that the Israelites had broken their covenant with Yahweh.
An Absent God
Thus, the kingdom of Abimelech was marked by deep spiritual unfaithfulness and confusion, and Judges emphasizes that the root of the chaos and slaughter of the period came not due to political failures but due to spiritual unfaithfulness. Throughout the narrative, Yahweh is largely absent. God is only mentioned three times. Each time, he is identified as Elohim, not his covenant name Yahweh, and each time he acts in judgment against Abimelech and the Shechemites (Judg 9:22, 56–57).28 Unlike the other narratives of Judges, in the Abimelech narrative, the people do not cry out to Yahweh, and Yahweh does not raise up a deliverer.
While Abimelech saw success in his re-conquest of Shechem, in his next campaign against Thebez, he is killed. Within Judges, Abimelech’s death repeats the pattern set by the death of Sisera at the hands of Jael—the oppressor’s head crushed by a woman using a household tool.29 But canonically, the skull-crushing deaths of both Sisera and Abimelech mark them out as the seed of the serpent (Judg 4:21–22; 5:24–27; 9:53; Gen 3:15). While sometimes listed as a judge because of his prominence in the narrative, Judges does not view Abimelech as a deliverer but rather as an oppressor like the other pagan nations. While Abimelech may have been Israelite in ethnicity, he lived in rebellion against Yahweh and brought destruction to God’s people and to himself as God’s judgment for their unfaithfulness.
The Interpretive Key of Jotham’s Fable
Jotham’s fable is the interpretive key for the entire Abimelech narrative.30 Considering the significance of the great tree in the setting of the story, readers should not be surprised by the arboreal focus of the fable. Jotham delivers his fable “from the head of Mount Gerizim.” The covenant of Israel literally overshadowed the city of Shechem with Gerizim and blessing to the south and Ebal and curse to the north. Considering the content of Jotham’s fable, one could argue that Mount Ebal, the mountain of curse, would be the more appropriate location for delivery, but perhaps in this irony lies the significance of Jotham’s choice—there is no blessing for a people in rebellion to Yahweh’s covenant.31 Only curse remains. There is no deliverer in the Abimelech narrative.
Prophetic Fable
In the fable, the trees, seeking to anoint a king, offer the kingdom to all the most obvious candidates: the olive tree, the fig tree, and the grapevine. But each refuse because each is satisfied with its own natural position and wealth. Finally, the trees offer the kingdom to the אָטָד, translated as “the bramble” (ESV, CSB) or “thornbush” (NIV) and possibly identified as the European boxthorn (Lycium europaeum).32 Silviu Tatu, however, argues that the אָטָד refers to a tree from the Ziziphus genus, which would have been quite proficient at giving shade, and thus the offer of the אָטָד to provide shade should not been read as false but parallels the evaluation of the other plants’ unique abilities. According to Tatu, Abimelech offers Shechem protection, but by accepting his protection, the leaders put themselves in a dangerous position, exposed to the fire that might come out of the tree.33 While Tatu’s reading remains possible, the ironic, even absurd, tone of the overall narrative favors the bramble or thornbush reading: Abimelech is an imposter king and has nothing but false promises and destruction to offer the people of Shechem.34
Kings and kingdoms are often pictured as trees in Scripture. For example, in Daniel, Nebuchadnezzar dreams of himself as a great tree, offering shade to the animals of the earth (Dan 4:1–27). Ezekiel presents the kingdom of Assyria as a cedar where animals find shade (Ezek 31:1–18).35 The promise of the bramble Abimelech, however, is a false promise. A thornbush may only offer minimal shade. In the end, only judgment will come to those who seek refuge under an imposter tree—a fire so great that even the mighty cedars of Lebanon will be consumed (Judg 9:15).
Prophetic Prefiguration
Jotham, speaking from one of the mounts of covenant renewal, prefigures the office of prophet in Israel as he enforces the covenant and proclaims future judgment.36 He proclaims that the anointing of Abimelech as king will result in both judgment for the baalim of Shechem and for Abimelech himself (Judg 9:20). Judges concludes the narrative by explicitly confirming the fulfillment of Jotham’s prophecy: “Thus God returned the evil of Abimelech…And God also made all the evil of the men of Shechem return on their heads, and upon them came the curse of Jotham the son of Jerubbaal” (Judg 9:56–57).
Israel needs a king who will lead the nation to obey Yahweh’s covenant and usher in the fulfillment of the promise to Abraham of a global kingdom where Yahweh dwells with his people, but not any king will do. Abimelech is an imposter, and he only brings curse rather than blessing. Abimelech is no deliverer, but the seed of the serpent whose head must be crushed. Under a broken covenant, every attempt at kingdom will fail because Yahweh not only abandons Israel but opposes Israel.
Conclusion
By highlighting the setting of the Abimelech narrative through a connection with the great tree at Shechem, the author of Judges 9 positions the story as a foil to the Abrahamic promise that was enacted and experienced at the same great tree in Genesis 12. The narrative of Abimelech functions as a microcosm of the history of Israel’s relationship to Yahweh. The culmination of Yahweh’s initial promise to Abram in Genesis 12 occurs when Yahweh appears to Abram at the great tree, foreshadowing a coming global kingdom where God would dwell with his people like in Eden. When Jacob’s sons attempt a failed conquest at Shechem in Genesis 35, Jacob calls his family to abandon their idols and bury them at the foot of the great tree, identifying exclusive commitment to Yahweh as prerequisite to receiving the promised kingdom. In Genesis, the great tree at Shechem echoes Eden and thus points forward to a promised kingdom that will restore humanity’s relationship with God. The tree can never truly be considered only as a tree but as a member of the forest.
Judges 9 draws from these Genesis stories to contrast Abimelech’s failed attempt at kingship with the promised kingdom to Abraham. Though crowned at the great tree where Yahweh appeared to Abram and where Joshua renewed the covenant with Israel and erected the stone of witness, Abimelech and the little baalim of Shechem serve a corrupted deity variously identified as Baal of the Covenant or El of the Covenant. But neither El nor Baal are the true God of the covenant, and despite his name, Abimelech is neither the son of a king nor a true king of Israel because of his alienation from Yahweh, the giver and goal of the promised kingdom. In fulfillment of his brother Jotham’s fable, Abimelech proves to be a mere bramble rather than the great tree that a true king of Israel will be.