I arrived on the field for my second and longest pastorate in the midst of the worst scandal in the church’s history. The day before, a male member of the church had been arrested for sexual assault against two underage boys who were also members of the church and whose parents were prominent members and friends of his. The perpetrator was a local police officer who moonlighted as a sheriff’s deputy doing river patrols. Multiple instances of sexual contact had occurred on the patrol boat.
I was skeptical about the authenticity of the perpetrator’s remorse and repentance, so in my first visit with him I expressed alarm at the seriousness of his sinful crimes. As I was emphasizing to him how grave his sins were, he broke in: “I’m confused by what you’re saying. You’re talking like what I’ve done is worse than other sins.”
“Yes, that is what I’m saying.”
He said, “But isn’t it true that sin is sin and no sin is worse than any other sin?”
I responded, “No, that’s not true for matters of morality. Some sins are definitely worse.”
He explained that he had battled against his lust and sought to put aside his fantasies, but the desires and fantasies persisted and intensified. Here’s the tragic turning point. After a period of ineffectual resistance to the sinful thoughts, he reasoned that since he couldn’t seem to find deliverance and since no sin is worse than any other sin, he might as well indulge in acting out his fantasies by grooming some boys into sexual contact. His faulty premise led to disastrous results. Notice that he perceived the comparative difference in pleasure but not in sinfulness.
This personal—and painful—pastoral recollection illustrates how critical this issue is. The case of that police officer is worse than many and is told here to shock the reader into attention. However, his rationale (the false equivalency of all sin) is common among evangelicals. If we do not correct this, untold others will be vulnerable to increasing sinfulness and its effects on themselves and others. Understanding that some sins are worse than others helps prevent a decline into worse and more harmful sins. Just as Christians seek to “grow in the grace and knowledge of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ” (2 Pet. 3:18), we must also guard against the risk of going “from bad to worse” (2 Tim. 3:13) and descending into “ever-increasing wickedness” (Rom. 6:19).1
This article has two theological aims and two behavioral aims. The first theological aim is to correct the errant ethical teaching that “sin is sin, and no sin is worse than any other sin,” defending instead the biblical concept of the gradation of sin. The second theological aim is to demonstrate how the potential to progress to worse sins is the antithetical corollary to the Christian doctrine of progressive sanctification.
The two behavioral aims are as follows. First, that we ourselves will be better protected from this illogic that could deceive us to proceed to worse sins and bring greater guilt and harm upon ourselves and others. Second, to motivate and equip us to teach and counsel others so that believers, and the people they may harm, will be dissuaded and protected from worse, more harmful sins.2
The Biblical Case that Some Sins Are Worse Than Others
The error this article seeks to correct is sometimes expressed as follows: “Sin is sin. No sin is worse than any other sin. All sins are equal in God’s eyes.”3 What makes this error insidious is that there is something that seems correct about it. It is true that with reference to salvation, the comparative severity of sins is inconsequential. Any and all sins are disastrous in relation to our perfectly holy and just God.4 The unbelieving ingrate, gossip, miser, and murderer are alike in their need of a Savior.5 Any sin, however minor it may seem, separates us from God, justifies our eternal condemnation, and necessitates the atoning sacrifice of Christ on our behalf.
The error occurs when the statement “Sin is sin” is amended to “All sins are equal” and is applied to ethics and morality.6 This is a false equivalence. There are myriad of different sins and they are different in many ways, including motivation, attitude, intentionality, overtness, indulgence, repetition, habitual practice, involvement of others, scope of damage, innocence of the victim, number of victims, responsibility to know better, abuse of authority, defensiveness, covering up, organization or programming of the sin, profiting from the sin, temporal or eternal consequences, and so on.7
Someone will object, “What about James 2:10, which says, ‘whoever keeps the whole law and yet stumbles at just one point is guilty of breaking all of it;’ does that not imply that all sins are equal?” No, it stresses that all commandments are important. It is another way of stating the point above, that any sin—or the transgression of any point in the law—makes one a guilty sinner.8
Scripture supports the doctrine of gradation of sin in three ways. First, it specifies different classifications of sins; second, it describes some sins or sinners as comparatively worse than others; and third, it warns against the risk of progressing into increasingly worse sinfulness.
Scripture Classifies Sins Differently
In John’s first epistle, he writes the following: “If you see any brother or sister commit a sin that does not lead to death, you should pray and God will give them life. I refer to those whose sin does not lead to death. There is a sin that leads to death. I am not saying that you should pray about that. All wrongdoing is sin, and there is sin that does not lead to death” (5:16–17). Here are two classifications of sin—deadly and non-deadly. Some sins are worse (leading to death) than others (that do not lead to death).9
Each of the synoptic Gospels includes the teaching of Jesus about the unpardonable sin of blasphemy against the Holy Spirit. In Mark 3:28–29, Jesus asserts, “Truly I tell you, people can be forgiven all their sins and every slander they utter, but whoever blasphemes against the Holy Spirit will never be forgiven; they are guilty of an eternal sin.”10
The Pentateuch refers to “crying sins,” such as Cain’s murder of Abel: “Your brother’s blood cries out to me from the ground” (Gen. 4:10).11 “Crying sins” are “sins that are especially grievous: sins committed against helpless, defenseless, or innocent people.”12
Numbers 15:22–31 distinguishes between intentional and unintentional sins. In verses 28 and 30 we read, “The priest is to make atonement before the Lord for the one who erred by sinning unintentionally, . . . but anyone who sins defiantly [lit. ‘with a high hand’], whether native-born or foreigner, blasphemes the Lord and must be cut off from the people of Israel.” As Jacob Milgrom observes, “The essence of this sin is that it is committed flauntingly.”13 Peter Enns, commenting on Exod. 21:12–14, points out that there “is a distinction between intentional, premeditated killing and unintentional, accidental killing.”14 A similar distinction is between sins committed in ignorance versus sins committed knowingly. Jesus himself declares that the latter will be punished more harshly (Luke 12:47–48).
Scripture Describes Some Sins or Sinners as Comparatively Worse
In this section, we will review Scriptures that describe various kinds of sins that bring various consequences or require different means of atonement, thus implying degrees of severity of the sins. In addition, this section will highlight passages that explicitly use comparative language regarding sins and sinners.
The Book of the Covenant (Exod. 20:22–23:33) includes case law distinguishing between various sinful acts, with corresponding variations in the punishment or required sacrifices or restitution. For example, if someone steals an ox or sheep and slaughters or sells it (so that owner cannot regain it), the perpetrator must pay back five-fold for the ox and four-fold for the sheep (Exod. 22:1). However, if the stolen livestock is recovered alive, the thief “must pay back double” (Exod. 22:4). So, here we see degrees of restitution for different circumstances involved in theft. However, for other sins (e.g., striking someone to kill them; kidnapping; cursing or attacking one’s parents) the penalty is as severe as death (Exod. 21:12–17).
The law of retaliation recognizes degrees of offense with corresponding degrees of punishment or restitution. “If anyone injures his neighbor, as he has done it shall be done to him, fracture for fracture, eye for eye, tooth for tooth; whatever injury he has given a person shall be given to him” (Lev. 24:19–20 ESV).15 J. A. Motyer comments that “this [law of retaliation] is often misused (as if ‘an eye for an eye’ was an expression of ancient savagery), but it is actually a poetic and dramatic demand that the punishment should match the crime, no more and no less.”16 It is not necessary to understand this in terms of literal retribution. William Johnstone writes, “The precept enunciates a basic principle of retributive and restorative justice: that punishment should be of equivalent severity to the crime committed and that the victim should receive equivalent restitution.”17 Jacob Weingreen explains, “The principle embodied in this formula is that anyone who unwittingly inflicts a loss upon another person must provide commensurate compensation.”18 The text trusts the reader to understand that the loss of a life is worse than the loss of an eye, which is worse than a bruise. Youth sometimes play a game called “Would you rather . . .?” The questions often pit two nearly equivalent choices against each other, whether desirable (e.g., ice cream vs. candy) or undesirable (e.g., flunk a class vs. not make the team). If we asked, “Would you rather someone slugs you in the arm or pokes your eye out?” the answer would be too obvious to fit the game.
The sacrificial system explained in Leviticus prescribes different sacrifices for different kinds of sins. Leviticus details the proper occasions for whole burnt offerings, sin offerings, guilt offerings, and so on, for various individual sins, while also prescribing the annual Day of Atonement with its sacrifices for the sins of the community as a whole. Some sins are addressed through these offerings and sacrifices, but others require restitution, being “cut off from the people,” or the death penalty. Intentionality is taken into consideration. As John Hartley notes, “The texts assume gradations of sin . . . The distinction between purification offerings, which were for sins of error, and reparation offerings, which were for accidental violations of the sacred and for restitutable offenses, further witnesses to a gradation in the kinds of sins . . . Thus the law recognizes lesser and greater sins.”19
The book of Kings describes multiple instances of evil or sinfulness or provoked divine anger using comparative language. “You [King Jeroboam] behaved more wickedly than all who were before you” (1 Kings 14:9 CSB). “Judah did evil in the eyes of the Lord. By the sins they committed they stirred up his jealous anger more than those who were before them had done” (1 Kings 14:22). “Ahab son of Omri did more evil in the eyes of the Lord than any of those before him” (1 Kings 16:30). “Manasseh led them astray, so that they did more evil than the nations the Lord had destroyed before the Israelites” (2 Kings 21:9). The text also charges Manasseh for causing Judah to sin (2 Kings 21:16). Peter Leithart points out that this represented a new nadir for the kings of Judah. Some twenty times the book of Kings indicts northern kings who “made Israel sin,” but “no king ‘makes Judah sin’ . . .––until Manasseh.”20 The Lord also says Manasseh “has done more evil than the Amorites who preceded him” (v. 11).
Ezekiel 16 is a judgment speech against Jerusalem, which is compared unfavorably to her “sisters,” the wicked cities of Samaria and Sodom: “You soon became more depraved than they” (v. 47). “Samaria did not commit half the sins you did. You have done more detestable things than they, and have made your sisters seem righteous by all these things you have done . . . Because your sins were more vile than theirs, they appear more righteous than you.” (vv. 51–52). Daniel Block provides a diagram that plots these cities on a continuum between righteousness and evil, showing that Samaria and Sodom are depicted as quite evil, but Jerusalem is even farther toward the evil end of the spectrum.21 Clearly, according to this prophetic passage, some sins are worse than others in the eyes of the Lord.
According to the Apostle John, Jesus himself uses comparative language in his statement to Pilate that “the one who handed me over to you is guilty of a greater sin” (John 19:11).22 The Jewish high priest bears the greater guilt because he of all people should have recognized and received the long-awaited Messiah rather than instigating his execution.
Jesus says in Mark 12:40 that the scribes who want deferential treatment and “devour widows’ houses and for a pretense make long prayers . . . will receive the greater condemnation” (ESV).
When Jesus is asked, “Which is the greatest commandment?” he names two (Mark 12:28–31; parallel Matt. 22:34–40). The comparative greatness of those commandments implies the comparative gravity of transgressing them.
In Matt. 23:23 Jesus pronounces woes on the scribes and Pharisees for tithing spices while neglecting “the more important matters of the law—justice, mercy and faithfulness. You should have practiced the latter, without neglecting the former.” He castigates them for not distinguishing between the “weightier” and the “trifling.”23
Gary Anderson’s monograph, Sin: A History, highlights the idea of sin as debt.24 Obviously, one can be in debt to varying degrees. In Luke 7:36–50, Jesus tells Simon the Pharisee a brief parable about two debtors, one who owed much and one who owed little, both of whom had their debts forgiven. Jesus asks Simon which debtor will love the creditor more? “Simon replied, ‘I suppose the one who had the bigger debt forgiven.’ ‘You have judged correctly,’ Jesus said” (v. 43).25
James warns, “Not many of you should become teachers, my fellow believers, because you know that we who teach will be judged more strictly” (James 3:1). Just as individuals with more light are more accountable, so it is for groups of people as represented by cities. In Matt. 11:20–24, “Jesus began to denounce the towns in which most of his miracles had been performed” (v. 20), pronouncing woes on them and declaring that “it will be more bearable for Sodom on the day of judgment than for you” (v. 24). Darrell Bock comments, “Cities that reject these messengers will have a more severe judgment, because more and greater revelation has come to them, making their sin worse.”26
Scripture Describes Some Sins or Sinners as Progressively Worse
Having established classifications of sins and their comparative severity, we now proceed to a logical consequence of these truths: since some sins are worse than others, it is possible to devolve from lesser to greater sins or from lesser to greater degrees of the same category of sin.
The book of Judges reports Israel’s cycles of rebellion. Judges 2:19 is germane to this study: “But when the judge died, the people returned to ways even more corrupt than those of their ancestor.” Block notes that “the successive generations became increasingly degenerate.”27 “Israel is depicted as . . . spiraling downward into worse and worse apostasy.”28 Block concludes, “The common repetitive view of this period must be modified. Not only do the patterns of evil repeat themselves; the treacherous behavior of the Israelites intensifies.”29
The Psalter opens with this declaration:
“How blessed is the man who does not walk in the counsel of the wicked,
Nor stand in the path of sinners,
Nor sit in the seat of scoffers!” (Ps. 1:1 NASB)
Allen Ross points out that “there is a threefold trilogy of ascending intensity.”30 The three terms for the worldly people (“wicked,” “sinners,” and “scoffers”), the three verbs (“walk,” “stand,” and “sit”), and the three nouns in the prepositional phrases (“counsel,” “path,” and “seat”) “correspond to this pattern of intensification.”31
In Rom. 6:19, Paul affirms gradations of sin, and more specifically, intensification of lawlessness. He commands, “Just as you used to offer yourselves as slaves to impurity and to ever-increasing wickedness, so now offer yourselves as slaves to righteousness leading to holiness.” The phrase “to ever-increasing wickedness” is τῇ ἀνομίᾳ εἰς τὴν ἀνομίαν. The CSB translates it “to greater and greater lawlessness,” while the ESV renders it “to lawlessness leading to more lawlessness.” James Dunn says the phrase carries “the implication of progressive deterioration, sin begetting sin.”32
In 2 Timothy, Paul uses the vocabulary of advance or progress related to increasing ungodliness or evil. He predicts, “Evildoers and impostors will go from bad to worse, deceiving and being deceived” (3:13). The phrase “will go from bad to worse” is from the Greek “προκόψουσιν ἐπὶ τὸ χεῖρον” (literally, “will progress to the worse”).33 Paul uses the same verb προκόπτω (“proceed,” “advance,” or “progress”) in 2:16: “they will make further progress in ungodliness” (NASB footnote).34 So, Scripture teaches that some people progress into worse ungodliness. John Owen warns that indwelling sin in Christians, if left alone, “will ultimately lead us to commit major, scandalous, and soul-destroying evil acts.”35 Owen continues: “Once [sin] gains a foothold in someone it constantly presses further onward to increasing degrees of depravity.”36 That is, unless we kill it.
Such is the biblical case for gradations of sin, a doctrine widely acknowledged by Judeo-Christian theologians. The Jewish rabbinic tradition recognized it.37 So has Roman Catholicism.38 Modern Protestant and evangelical theologians supporting gradations of sin include Herman Bavinck, Emil Brunner, Louis Berkof, Reinhold Niebuhr, Berkouwer, Wayne Grudem, Wolfhart Pannenberg, Cornelius Plantinga Jr., Norman Geisler, and Thomas McCall.39 Let us turn now to the second aim of this article.
Progressive Sanctification and the Avoidance of Progressive Sinfulness
How should we apply this biblical doctrine of gradations of sins? It relates to sanctification—the process by which believers become more holy. Our greater clarity on gradations of sin fits well with the Reformed Evangelical view of sanctification, which understands it to be a gradual process of becoming holy that is most essentially God’s work, but which also calls for Christian cooperation, effort, discipline, and struggle. Bruce Demarest explains and advocates this position, and other evangelicals concur.40 Whereas our justification occurs instantaneously—in a moment—our sanctification is an ongoing, lifelong process.41 Furthermore, one is either justified or not; there are no degrees of justification. However, there are degrees of sanctification; it is progressive.42 The verbs in the phrases “grow (αὐξάνατε) in the grace and knowledge of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ” (2 Pet. 3:18), “perfecting (ἐπιτελοῦντες) holiness out of reverence for God” (2 Cor. 7:1), and “those who are being sanctified (ἁγιαζομένους)” (Heb. 10:14 ESV) are all in the Greek present tense, which can indicate continuous, ongoing action. Degrees of sanctification or progressive sanctification are the other side of the coin from degrees of sinfulness or progressive sinfulness. Should we progress in sinfulness when we are called to progress in holiness? May it never be!
This is especially relevant for ministers, because we are to be exemplary in character and conduct (Phil. 3:17; 1 Tim. 4:11; 1 Pet. 5:3). Richard Baxter exhorts his fellow pastors, “Take heed to yourselves, for you have a depraved nature, and sinful inclinations, as well as others.”43
God has begun the work of sanctification in us, and he will most assuredly complete it (Rom. 8:29; Phil. 1:6; 1 Thess. 5:23–24). Without his effectual work, there could be no progress. However, we believers participate in this process. The indicative of God’s spiritual provision of new life is paramount, but it does not exclude the imperative of Christian activity. Kenneth Boa provides a list of biblical passages that show “the interrelationship of the human and the divine in the outworking of the Christian life.”44 Donald Bloesch explains that believers are justified but also are still sinners. Therefore, “the Christian life is a striving towards victory rather than a matured possession of victory. The life of faith is a life of conflict and struggle.”45 Herman Ridderbos agrees, stating that Paul “describes the life of believers time and again from the double viewpoint of battling on the basis of victory and of gaining the victory on the basis of the battle.”46 We labor and strive, but it is with his strength that powerfully works within us (Col. 1:29). We are to be obedient and work out our salvation, but “with fear and trembling, for it is God who works in you to will and to act in order to fulfill his good purpose” (Phil. 2:12–13). God’s “divine power,” the Apostle Peter writes, “has given us everything we need for a godly life,” enabling us to escape “the corruption in the world caused by evil desires” (2 Pet. 1:3–4). Because of this, we are to “make every effort” to add one virtue to another in a chain from faith through love (2 Pet. 1:5–8). God’s intent is that we will “possess these qualities in increasing measure” (2 Pet. 1:8).
What is the relationship between God’s work and our responsibility in this growth in moral excellence? As Thomas Schreiner states, “The indicative of God’s gift precedes and undergirds the imperative that calls for human exertion.”47 Douglas Moo agrees: “We must make room in our understanding of sanctification for both the divine and the human side. We must insist both that it is God, by his Spirit, who makes us holy and that it is we, ourselves, who have the job of becoming holy.”48 Jerry Bridges explains it this way:
Progressive sanctification very much involves our activity. But it is an activity that must be carried out in dependence on the Holy Spirit. It is not a partnership with the Spirit in the sense that we each—the believer and the Holy Spirit—do our respective tasks. Rather, we work as He enables us to work. His work lies behind all our work and makes our work possible.49
Demarest highlights the negative and positive aspects of progressive sanctification, which supports the antithetical correlation of gradations of sin and progressive sanctification.50 In Rom. 6:19 the former offering of the parts of ourselves as slaves of lawlessness resulting in further lawlessness is contrasted with the exhortation to “now offer them as slaves to righteousness, which leads to sanctification.” The two halves of this formulaic sentence are antithetical to each other. Just as the first clause speaks of progressive intensification in lawlessness, the parallel second clause “refers to the process of becoming more and more holy.”51 Paul is warning about the former and promoting the latter. There is a negative component matched by an antithetically parallel positive component. Far be it from us to “make further progress in ungodliness” (2 Tim. 2:16 NASB footnote) or “progress to the worse” (2 Tim. 3:13 Lexham English Bible) when we should be progressing in holiness. C. S. Lewis says that choice by choice one becomes either “a heavenly creature” or “a hellish creature.”52 Schreiner concurs: “Each of us at each moment is progressing to the one state or the other.”53 Wayne Grudem warns that “as a result of willful sin, we will slide backward in our sanctification . . . becoming increasingly enslaved to . . . sin.”54
We should follow the apostolic example and teaching to apply the negative and positive simultaneously. The following string of quotations reveals the prevalence of this New Testament concept. “Forgetting what is behind” (the negative) and “and straining toward what is ahead,” we can “press on toward the goal to win the prize for which God has called [us] heavenward in Christ Jesus” (the positive) (Phil. 3:13–14). We should consider ourselves dead to sin (negative) and alive to God in Christ Jesus (positive) (Rom. 6:11). We must stop presenting the parts of our bodies to sin as instruments of unrighteousness (negative) but instead present our parts to God as instruments of righteousness (positive) (Rom. 6:12–13). We can stop being obedient as slaves to sin and keep being obedient to righteousness (Rom. 6:16). “Let us throw off everything that hinders and the sin that so easily entangles. And let us run with perseverance the race marked out for us, fixing our eyes on Jesus” (Heb. 12:1–2). We must keep on repenting and keep on believing the good news (Mark 1:15). We are to put aside vices while we also put on virtues (Col. 3:8, 12). We can put to death the deeds of the body and really live (Rom. 8:13). We must not sow to the flesh and reap corruption but instead sow to the Spirit and reap eternal life (Gal. 6:8). We should not set our minds on the things of the flesh but on the things of the Spirit (Rom. 8:5–7). “Let us purify ourselves from everything that contaminates body and spirit, perfecting holiness out of reverence for God” (2 Cor. 7:1). We must “resist the devil” and “draw near to God” (James 4:7–8 ESV). We are not to be conformed to the desires of our former ignorance, but as the One who called us is holy, we also are to be holy in all our conduct (1 Pet. 1:14–15). We should walk by the Spirit so we will not carry out the desires of the flesh (Gal. 5:16). We “who belong to Christ Jesus have crucified the flesh with its passions and desires. Since we live by the Spirit, let us keep in step with the Spirit” (Gal. 5:24–25). We must stop loving the world and instead love God (1 John 2:15–16). We must stop being conformed to the world and instead be transformed by the renewing of our minds (Rom. 12:2). If we want to be authentic disciples, we must keep on denying ourselves as we keep on following Christ (Luke 9:23). As we lose our lives, we will find our lives in Christ (Matt. 10:39; 16:25; Mark 8:35; John 12:25). All these exhortations and imperatives are consistent with God’s negative and positive work on our behalf: he has crucified our old self with Christ and made us alive with Christ (Rom. 6:6; Eph. 2:5).
Lewis makes the practical application to our lives, expressing it both positively and negatively. He writes:
Good and evil both increase at compound interest. That is why the little decisions you and I make every day are of such infinite importance. The smallest good act today is the capture of a strategic point from which, a few months later, you may be able to go on to victories you never dreamed of. [Conversely], an apparently trivial indulgence in lust or anger today is the loss of a ridge or railway line or bridgehead from which the enemy may launch an attack otherwise impossible.55
In her book Glittering Vices, Rebecca DeYoung warns that “both virtues and vices are habits that can eventually become ‘natural’ to us . . . If cultivating virtue and avoiding vice is the key to moral formation, then we need to know first of all what the particular virtues and vices are.”56
Conclusion
This article began with the cautionary tale of a man who progressed from fantasies about underage boys to manipulating them into homosexual acts. This resulted in his incarceration and was spiritually and emotionally harmful to those boys, their families, our church, and our community. That was an extreme case, and if we can disciple people in ways to prevent such twisted progression into worse sins, we should. However, this article is not only motivated by that case. It is also motivated by my own lifelong struggle against various sins. I assume your experience is similar to mine. As Lewis asserts, we who struggle against sin are actually much more expert about it than those who blithely give in to it and indulge in it.57
This article demonstrates three ways Scripture teaches gradation of sins: 1) it describes classifications of sins; 2) it describes some sins or sinners as comparatively worse than others; and 3) it warns against the risk of progressing into worse sinfulness.
Clarity on gradations of sin motivates believers to avoid progress in sinfulness as they also progress in sanctification. The effortful obedience of believers cooperates with the sanctifying work of God to attain greater degrees of moral excellence. The ethical teachings of Jesus and New Testament authors support the antithetical correlation of progressive sanctification and gradation of sin. This prompts believers to join God in two simultaneous endeavors: avoidance of sin and growth in righteousness.
For practical application, let us use the familiar sin of lust as our example. Failures in this arena have wreaked havoc on the church and her witness. Dorothy Sayers tells of a young man who said to her, “I did not know there were seven deadly sins: please tell me the names of the other six?”58 Apparently one of them was self-evident, and she assumes we can all guess which one that is. Focusing on this one category of sin—the lust continuum—will illustrate that part of “the deceitfulness of sin” (Heb. 3:13 ESV) is how it “presses on to some farther degrees in the same kind.”59
As believers called out of progress in sinfulness and into progress in sanctification, we should be guided by an awareness of the comparative sinfulness of various thoughts, actions, and practices on the lust continuum. To objectify another human being we see for our own mental sexual enjoyment is a sin of lust. To seek out still images designed to excite that lust is worse. To seek out pornographic video is worse. Going to a live strip club and buying a lap dance from a dancer is worse. Hiring a prostitute is worse. Raping someone is worse. Kidnapping someone and making them your sex slave is worse.
Consider a different progression. Entertaining sexual fantasies about a married acquaintance is a sin. Flirting with that person to explore their interest is a worse sin. Attempting a sexual advance with them is worse. Physically committing adultery with them is worse. Habitually seducing a series of people into adulterous affairs is worse yet. Believers with moral clarity on the gradations of sins like lust will have greater motivation not to progress into worse ungodliness. Conversely, those who flatten out every manifestation of sins like lust to equal severity are susceptible to a worsening of sinful indulgence. This in turn leads to more dire consequences such as fractured relationships, divorce, devastated children, a decrease in ministry effectiveness or opportunity, reproach on the church and the name of Christ, and variations in intensity regarding pathways for repentance, restoration, and restitution. Could it be that ministry leaders who commit adultery are unclear about the gradations of worse and worse sins that culminate in that scandalous act? It should not be so.
The world—and even some of our Christian friends—will not understand our commitment to sexual purity (or other attempts at progress in holiness). They may think we are unrealistic or prudish. So be it. We can stand firm and be strong in the strength of the Lord (Eph. 6:10, 13–14). Let us “come out from them and be separate” (2 Cor. 6:17).
By labeling some expressions of lust as more sinful than others, are we excusing or recommending the lesser sins of lust? Certainly not! That is the point of Matt. 5:27–28—that any lust, even in our hearts, is sin, and must be resisted and overcome. Therefore, not only do we not commit adultery, but we do not flirt. Not only do we not watch live strippers, but we take measures to avoid provocative sensual images on our electronic devices. Not only do we not go looking for arousing images, but we cultivate the practice of “bouncing our eyes” away from lustfully tempting images we encounter.60 Why would we seek to live this way? Because Scripture says, “Dear friends, I urge you, as foreigners and exiles, to abstain from sinful desires, which wage war against your soul,” (1 Pet. 2:11) and because some sins are worse than others, and because “lesser sticks set the great ones on fire.”61
We could sketch out gradations of other sins on their own continuums, such as anger/violence, or greed/theft. However, we should not presume to think we could perfectly rank every variation in order, nor should we trust ourselves to do so. If we attempt that, we will find ourselves descending down another sin continuum—one of pride, aggravated by a judgmental attitude. Let us seek to maintain a pure motive in our application of the truth of the gradation of sin: to guard against our own real risk of sliding deeper into worse sins, which flouts God’s program of sanctifying us. From that humble perspective, we will be able to help others who need a word of instruction or admonition about their sins. Planks are bigger than specks of sawdust, but Jesus does not want us to let either remain in our eyes or the eyes of fellow believers (Matt. 7:3–5). Also, the human component of sanctification cannot proceed successfully in isolation; we need one another. “Speaking the truth in love, we are to grow up in every way into him who is the head, into Christ” (Eph. 4:15 ESV). Each of us is prone to subjective blind spots. We need spiritual intimacy with other believers that includes loving truth-telling aimed at progress in sanctification.
Being “holier than thou” should not be our claim or goal. Our goal should be to be holier a year from now than we are today. It is by God’s grace that any of us is holier—and less sinful—today than we were ten years ago. But each of us still has a long way to go. We can be “confident of this, that he who began a good work in [us] will carry it on to completion until the day of Christ Jesus” (Phil. 1:6). Let us radically depend on God to continue that work, and let us also exert ourselves to that same end, by his power, which mightily works within us (Col. 1:29).